Vanilla ice cream loaded with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Rum Raisin Ice Cream
Sweet cream ice cream mixed with rum-marinated raisins. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Strawberry Ice Cream
Sweet cream ice cream mixed with pureed strawberries. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Coconut Almond Chip Ice Cream
Cream of coconut ice cream with shredded coconut, toasted almonds, and bittersweet chocolate chips. Gluten-free. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Coffee Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
Full-strength coffee ice cream with chunks of chocolate & cream cookies hand-stirred in. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Pistachio Ice Cream
Sweet cream ice cream mixed with pistachio chunks and almond extract. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Sweet Cream Ice Cream
Gluten-free. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Mint Chip Ice Cream
Peppermint ice cream with bittersweet chocolate chips. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Salted Caramel Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
Salted Caramel ice cream loaded with crushed cookies. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Lactose Free Madagascar Vanilla Ice Cream
Our classic vanilla recipe added to our special lactose-free ice cream base. Contains dairy! Vegetarian.
$8.15
Fresh Peach Ice Cream
We cut over 15 cases of peaches a week by hand and marinate them in brown sugar for this summer favorite. Only ever available during peach season. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Hard Frozen Yogurt Flavors
Coffee Chip Yogurt
Coffee frozen yogurt and bittersweet chocolate chips. Vegetarian and gluten-free.
$8.15
Peanut Butter Chip Yogurt
Peanut butter frozen yogurt and bittersweet chocolate chips. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Mint Chip Yogurt
Peppermint frozen yogurt mixed with bittersweet chocolate chips. Gluten-free and vegetarian.
$8.15
Oatmeal Cookie Yogurt
Loads of oatmeal cookies crushed up and added to our frozen yogurt. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Cookies 'n' Cream Hard Yogurt
Low-fat hard yogurt loaded with chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies hand-stirred in. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Black Raspberry Chip Hard Yogurt
Black raspberry hard yogurt loaded with chocolate chips. Vegetarian.
$8.15
Dairy-Free Ice Cream Flavors
Chocolate-Coconut Dairy-free Ice Cream
Our dairy-free coconut base blended with rich cocoa powder. Gluten-free and vegan.
$8.15
Sundae
The Traditional Sundae
Vanilla ice cream, homemade hot fudge, crushed walnuts and topped with whipped cream. Vegetarian. Sundaes are medium size only and come packed in a pint container. All wet toppings will come on the side for quality purposes.
$11.25
Cookielishous Sundae
Cookies and cream cake batter ice cream with crushed cookies and our homemade hot fudge topped with whipped cream. Vegetarian. Sundaes are medium size only and come packed in a pint container. All wet toppings will come on the side for quality purposes.
$11.25
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Vanilla ice cream, peanut butter sauce, homemade hot fudge, and a peanut butter cup and topped with whipped cream. Vegetarian. Sundaes are medium size only and come packed in a pint container. All wet toppings will come on the side for quality purposes.
$11.69
Brownie Batter Ice Cream Sundae
Chocolate brownie batter brownie ice cream with homemade hot fudge and mini chocolate chips with whipped cream. Vegetarian. Sundaes are medium size only and come packed in a pint container. All wet toppings will come on the side for quality purposes.
$11.25
Mint Cookies & Cream Sundae
Mint cookies and cream ice cream with homemade hot fudge, crushed cookies and topped with whipped cream. Vegetarian. Sundaes are medium size only and come packed in a pint container. All wet toppings will come on the side for quality purposes.
$11.25
Hand Packed Ice Cream Cakes
6" Cookies & Cream Baby Cake
Serves 6-10. 6" round. 2 layers of cookies and cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The sides are wrapped in crushed cookies and Oreo halves top the cake.
$41.79
6" Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Baby Cake
Serves 5–10. 6" round. 2 layers of chocolate chip ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The sides of the cake are wrapped in chocolate sprinkles.
$33.95
6" Cookies & Cream with Vanilla Yogurt Baby Cake
Serves 6-10. 6" round. 1 layer of cookies and cream yogurt and 1 of vanilla yogurt with fudge nestled in the center wrapped in crushed Oreos and Oreo halves top the cake.
$41.79
6" Chocolate Covered Cookies & Cream Baby Cake
Serves 6-10. 6" round. 2 layers of cookies and cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The whole cake is enveloped in creamy chocolate ganache and finished with Pirouline cookies and chocolate shavings.
$48.35
8" Cookies & Cream Medium Cake
Serves 8–15. 8" round. 2 layers of cookies and cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The sides are wrapped in crushed cookies and Oreo halves top the cake.
$54.85
8" Coffee Cookies & Cream Medium Cake
Serves 8-15. 8" round. 2 layers of our creamy coffee cookies and cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. We frost the cake with our coffee whip topping and top with crushed cookies and fudge.
$54.85
8" Cookies & Cake Batter Surprise Medium Cake
Serves 8 - 15. 8" round. Medium cake. Two layers of our Cookies 'n' Cake Batter ice cream with a center of rainbow sprinkles. Then the entire cake is enveloped in rainbow sprinkles.
$54.85
10" Cookies & Cream Large Cake
Serves 12 - 20. 10" round. 2 layers of cookies and cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The sides are wrapped in crushed cookies and Oreo halves top the cake.
$67.90
8" MooLaLa Medium Cake
Serves 8-15. 8" round. Vanilla and chocolate ice cream with a homemade fudge center decorated with J.P. Licks sprinkles and pink frosting. Gluten-free.
$54.85
Specialty Square Cakes
Tiramisu Cake
Serves 4-6. Incredible tiramisu ice cream stacked between thin layers of moist cake, garnished with fudge and a sprinkle of cocoa. Rave Reviews! Vegetarian.
$28.75
Brownie Layer Cake
Serves 4 - 6. Rich and chewy chocolate brownie layered with vanilla ice cream. Very elegant and very good! Vegetarian.
$28.75
Toppings & Extras
1/2 Pint of Toppings
Choose a 1/2 pint of your favorite topping to add to your pints or quarts.
$5.79
Candles
$2.39
Single Serving of Toppings
Add a single serving of your favorite toppings to a medium cup of ice cream.
$1.69
Party Packs
5 Person Sundae Pack
Serves up to 5 people. 1 quart ice cream, 8 oz of a wet topping of your choice, 5 oz of the dry topping of your choice, half a pint of whipped cream, cups, and spoons and napkins for 5.