5.06 mi
Pizza
American
Sandwiches
Burgers
American (new)
1189 Bay St, Staten Island, NY, 10305
Sat 12:00 PM - 10:45 PM
J's On The Bay
If you're looking for American (new) restaurants in Staten Island look no further. J's On The Bay is known for having some of the best American (new) in Staten Island. Located at 1189 Bay St, J's On The Bay is a great place to dine in or order delivery or takeout. It's the perfect option for those searching for "American (new) Near Me". They have tons of great options, so scroll down to see the J's On The Bay menu and pick your favorites.
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Menu
- Open Dining
- DoorDash
- Slice
PIZZA
MARGARITA PIZZA (0)
SAN MARZANO D.O.P. TOMATO + FRESH MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + BASIL
$10.00
MARGARITA PIZZA (12 INCH)
SAN MARZANO D.O.P. TOMATO + FRESH MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + BASIL
$10.00
GREAT WHITE (0)
SMOKED MOZZARELLA + RICOTTA + GORGONZOLA CREAM + FRESH MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + ARUGULA + TRUFFLE HONEY REDUCTION
$16.00
GREAT WHITE (12 INCH)
SMOKED MOZZARELLA + RICOTTA + GORGONZOLA CREAM + FRESH MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + ARUGULA + TRUFFLE HONEY REDUCTION
$16.00
SPINACH & ARTICHOKE (0)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + GORGONZOLA CREAM + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + BABY ORGANIC SPINACH + MARINATED ARTICHOKE HEARTS
$15.00
SPINACH & ARTICHOKE (12 INCH)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + GORGONZOLA CREAM + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + BABY ORGANIC SPINACH + MARINATED ARTICHOKE HEARTS
$15.00
ANGRY LOBSTER (0)
BUTTER POACHED MAINE LOBSTER + FRESH MOZZARELLA + SMOKED MOZZARELLA + ROASTED TOMATO LOBSTER CREAM + HABANERO TABASCO
$19.00
ANGRY LOBSTER (12 INCH)
BUTTER POACHED MAINE LOBSTER + FRESH MOZZARELLA + SMOKED MOZZARELLA + ROASTED TOMATO LOBSTER CREAM + HABANERO TABASCO
$19.00
THE 4 SEASONS (0)
SAN MARZANO D.O.P TOMATO + FRESH MOZZARELLA + GAETA OLIVES + WILD MUSHROOMS + MARINATED ARTICHOKE HEARTS + SMOKED SPECK
$16.00
THE 4 SEASONS (12)
SAN MARZANO D.O.P TOMATO + FRESH MOZZARELLA + GAETA OLIVES + WILD MUSHROOMS + MARINATED ARTICHOKE HEARTS + SMOKED SPECK
$16.00
FRENCH ONION PIZZA (0)
GRUYERE CHEESE + FRESH MOZZARELLA + BEEF DEMI CARAMELIZED ONIONS + PANKO CRUST
$15.00
FRENCH ONION PIZZA (12)
GRUYERE CHEESE + FRESH MOZZARELLA + BEEF DEMI CARAMELIZED ONIONS + PANKO CRUST
$15.00
LA FRESCA (0)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + SMOKED MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + VINE GRAPE TOMATOES + SHAVED MUSHROOMS + BALSAMIC REDUCTION
$13.00
LA FRESCA (12)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + SMOKED MOZZARELLA + PARMIGIANO REGGIANO + VINE GRAPE TOMATOES + SHAVED MUSHROOMS + BALSAMIC REDUCTION
$13.00
THE CHICKEN N WAFFLE (0)
SHARP CHEDDAR CHEESE + BACON ONION JAM + CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN BREAST + CHIPOTLE MAYO
$16.00
THE CHICKEN N WAFFLE (12)
SHARP CHEDDAR CHEESE + BACON ONION JAM + CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN BREAST + CHIPOTLE MAYO
$16.00
J'S FAMOUS BREAKFAST PIZZA (0)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + SWEET FENNEL SAUSAGE + BANANA PEPPERS + SUN-DRIED TOMATOES + CARAMELIZED ONIONS + SCRAMBLED EGGS
$12.00
J'S FAMOUS BREAKFAST PIZZA (12 INCH)
FRESH MOZZARELLA + SWEET FENNEL SAUSAGE + BANANA PEPPERS + SUN-DRIED TOMATOES + CARAMELIZED ONIONS + SCRAMBLED EGGS
$12.00
THE HANGOVER PIE (0)
vodka sauce + smoked mozzarella + fresh mozzarella + sweet green peas + crispy smoked speck
$17.00
THE HANGOVER PIE (12 INCH)
vodka sauce + smoked mozzarella + fresh mozzarella + sweet green peas + crispy smoked speck
$17.00
J's Specials
ST LOUIS BABY BACK RIBS
cinnamon chipotle rub + chipotle brown sugar bbq sauce + mac n cheese + honey butter corn bread
$18.00
SUMMER PEACH BURRATA SALAD
grilled summer peach + spiced pineapple puree + arugula + shaved macadamia nuts + grilled sour dough
$13.00
BBQ BEEF SHORT RIB
cinnamon chipotle rub + chipotle brown sugar bbq sauce + fingerling & string bean salad + honey butter corn bread
$25.00
THE HANGOVER PIE
vodka sauce + smoked mozzarella + fresh mozzarella + sweet green peas + crispy smoked speck
$17.00
CORN BREAD & GRAVY
jalapeño corn bread + maple sausage gravy + sunny side up egg + sweet pickled pepper + mixed green salad
$15.00
MAHI MAHI SHRIMP
GRILLED SHRIMP + JALAPANO CORN BREAD + SPICED PINEAPPLE PUREE + CHIPOTLE CINNAMON BBQ SAUCE + GRILLED PEACH SALSA + PICKLED SWEET PEPPERS
$21.00
MACERATED BERRY FRENCH TOAST
chocolate bread + molten white chocolate + whipped cream + maple sugar dust
$12.00
HABANERO CANTELOUPE GAZPACHO
crab + avocado + pickled onion
$8.00
KUNG POW CAULIFLOWER
mixed bell peppers + roasted peanuts + black sesame + scallion
$13.00
↳ Egg Sandwiches
Potatoes and Eggs
2 eggs any style + home fries + choice of cheese + choice of meat
$6.00
Peppers and Eggs
2 eggs any style + sauteed peppers + choice of cheese + choice of meat
$6.00
2 Eggs w/ Meat (without cheese)
2 eggs any style + choice of bread + choice of meat
$5.50
2 Eggs (without cheese)
2 eggs any style + choice of bread
$3.00
2 Eggs w/ Cheese
2 eggs any style + choice of bread + choice of cheese
$4.00
↳ Egg Platters
J's Hungry Man
2 eggs any style + choice of meat + choice of toast + choice of potatoes + choice of pancakes, french toast, or waffles
+ small orange juice
$17.00
J's Bacon, Egg & Cheese
two eggs up + bacon + crunch croustinis + cheddar cheese + fried spinach + choice of potatoes
$13.00
2 Eggs Any Style w/ Potatoes (0)
2 eggs any style + choice of potatoes + choice of toast + choice of meat (optional)
$9.00
2 Eggs Any Style w/ Potatoes (with meat)
2 eggs any style + choice of potatoes + choice of toast + choice of meat (optional)
$12.00
Steak n Eggs
8 oz NY Strip + 2 Eggs Any Style + Garlic Roasted Potatoes + Maple Compound Butter
$25.00
↳ Omelettes
Build Your Own Omelette
Start with 2 eggs, choice of 1 meat + 1 vegetable + 1 cheese, choice of potatoes & choice of toast
$9.00
Chicken Florentine
grilled chicken + baby spinach + mushrooms + swiss cheese + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$11.00
The Italian
roasted peppers + baby spinach + sweet sausage + caramelized onions + fresh mozzarella + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$12.00
J's Famous
banana peppers + sun-dried tomatoes + caramelized onions + sweet sausage + fresh mozzarella + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$12.00
South of the Border
chorizo + caramelized onions + banana peppers + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
Pork Cheddar
bacon + cheddar cheese + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
Three Cheese
fresh mozzarella + swiss + cheddar + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
Ham Melt
ham + swiss + cheddar + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
Fresca
spinach + tomato + mushrooms + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
Broccoli and Cheese
sautéed broccoli + swiss, cheddar, or fresh mozzarella + choice of potatoes + choice of toast
$10.00
↳ Hot off the Griddle
French Batter Croissant (without meat)
topped w/ nutella mascarpone + choice of meat (optional) + berries (optional)
$10.00
French Batter Croissant (with meat)
topped w/ nutella mascarpone + choice of meat (optional) + berries (optional)
$12.00
French Toast (without meat)
Choice of meat: bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, chicken and chorizo
$9.00
Pancakes (without meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$9.00
Pancakes (with meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$11.00
Short Stack of Pancakes (without meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$8.00
Short Stack of Pancakes (with meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$10.00
Silver Dollar Pancakes (without meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$8.00
Silver Dollar Pancakes (with meat)
Choice of meat includes bacon, ham, sausage, turkey bacon, or chorizo
$10.00
Waffle
Choice of Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Turkey Bacon, Chorizo
$9.00
↳ Sides & Add-on's
J's Parmesan French Fries
tossed with fresh herbs + J's chipotle mayo on side
$8.00
J's Caramel Sweet Potato Fries
$7.00
Regular Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Chorizo
$4.00
Market Fresh Fruit
$5.00
Regular French Fries
$4.00
J's Side Salad
house market salad with pickled red onions
$4.00
J's Home Fries
peppers + onions
$3.00
Bacon • Sausage • Ham • Turkey Bacon
side dish of your choice of meat
$3.00
English Muffin
toasted or un-toasted + butter or cream cheese
$1.00
Toast
white, rye or whole wheat.
$1.00
Hash Browns (2 pcs)
$3.00
Add Fresh Mozzarella
add fresh mozzarella to your dish.
$2.00
Add Cheese
add american, swiss or cheddar
$2.00
Salt n Vinegar Fries
Chipotle Ketchup
$7.00
↳ Cereal & Baked Goods
Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal
cinnamon + berries (optional) + walnuts (optional)
$4.00
Bowl of Oatmeal
Choice of berries (optional) + walnuts (optional)
$3.50
Bowl of Cereal
Raisin Bran Crunch + Special K + Lucky Charms + Apple Jacks
$3.00
Bagel w/ Butter
toasted, un-toasted + butter
$1.75
Bagel w/ Cream Cheese
toasted or un-toasted + cream cheese
$2.25
Bialy w/ Butter
toasted, un-toasted + butter
$2.00
Bialy w/ Cream Cheese
toasted, un-toasted + cream cheese
$2.50
English Muffin
toasted or un-toasted + butter or cream cheese
$1.00
Muffin (Price)
corn or blueberry, toasted, un toasted + butter
$2.50
↳ Appetizers
Sesame Kung "Pow" Chicken Wings
8 pcs Party Wing + Bell Peppers + Peanuts + Spicy Kung "Pow" Sauce
$12.00
Fire Cracker Calamari
topped w/ banana pepper cherry tomato relish
$13.00
Fresh Mozzarella Avocado Caprese
mozzarella + tomato + avocado + balsamic reduction
$10.00
Sweet Potato Croquettes (3 pcs)
J's maple-soy brown butter dipping sauce
$9.00
Parmesan French Fries
tossed with fresh herbs + parmesan cheese + J's chipotle mayo
$8.00
Lobster Rangoons
Herb Infused Cream Cheese + Smoked Mozzarella + Green Onion Jam
$14.00
↳ Lunch Special
Lunch Special
Any half portion sandwich (NO Grilled Cheese) + choice of french fries, J's parmesan fries, small soup or salad + can of soda or bottled water
$12.50
Open Faced Sandwiches
J's Chicken & Waffles
fried chicken + waffle + bacon onion jam + melted cheddar cheese + J's chipotle mayo
$17.00
Open-Faced Roast Beef
roast beef + mixed greens + tomatoes + pickled red onions + horseradish cream
$12.00
Tuna Croissant
tuna salad on a croissant + mixed greens + melted cheddar cheese
$12.00
Open Faced Lobster Roll
Butter Poached Main Lobster + Roasted Corn Aioli + Arugula + Buttery Brioche Bread
$21.00
↳ Salads
J's Chopped Salad
romaine hearts + cherry tomatoes + cucumbers + gaeta olives + pickled red onion + sunflower seeds + creamy basil dressing
$11.00
Apple Walnut Salad
spring mix + mescaline salad + dried cranberries + candied walnuts + granny smith apples + goat cheese + honey balsamic reduction
$11.00
Baby Spinach Salad
roasted peppers + sun-dried tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + gaeta olives + balsamic & oil dressing
$10.00
Farmers Market Salad
baby greens + cherry tomatoes + carrots + cucumbers + apples + pickled red onions + honey balsamic dressing
$10.00
Caesar Salad
tender romaine hearts + croutons + parmesan cheese + caesar dressing
$10.00
B.P.A Quinoa
Crispy Bacon Lardons + Avocado + Fresh Mozzarella + Grape Tomatoes + Toasted Pine Nuts + Creamy Basil
$12.00
↳ Burgers
J's Steakhouse Burger (Standard)
sautéed mushrooms + caramelized onions + Lioni's fresh mozzarella + upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$10.00
J's Steakhouse Burger (Deluxe)
sautéed mushrooms + caramelized onions + Lioni's fresh mozzarella + upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$12.00
Standard Handcrafted Bacon Burger (Standard)
lettuce + tomato + pickle + choice of fries
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$9.00
Standard Handcrafted Bacon Burger (Deluxe)
lettuce + tomato + pickle + choice of fries
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$11.00
Standard Handcrafted Cheese Burger (Standard)
lettuce + tomato + pickle + choice of cheese
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$9.00
Standard Handcrafted Cheese Burger (Deluxe)
lettuce + tomato + pickle + choice of cheese
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$10.00
Standard Handcrafted Burger (Standard)
lettuce + tomato + pickle
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$7.00
Standard Handcrafted Burger (Deluxe)
lettuce + tomato + pickle
upgrade to deluxe for choice of fries
$9.00
↳ Sandwiches
The Roast Beef
thinly sliced roast beed + caramelized onions + fresh mozzarella + J's demi glaze
$13.00
Asian Steak Sandwich
teriyaki marinated sirloin steak + fire roasted peppers + fresh mozzarella
$13.00
Double Smoked BLT
double smoked slab bacon + field greens + avocado + caramelized cherry tomato shallot relish
$12.00
Truffle Chicken Salad
J's chicken salad + granny smith apples + dried cranberries +avocado
$11.00
Chicken Florentine
grilled chicken + sautéed mushrooms + cherry tomatoes + wilted baby spinach + melted swiss cheese + truffle honey reduction
$10.00
Tuscan Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken + sun-dried tomatoes + field greens + shaed parmesan cheese + balsamic reduction
$10.00
Italian Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken + fire roasted peppers + field greens + pesto + balsamic reduction
$10.00
J's BPA Grilled Cheese
bacon + pesto + avocado + mozzarella cheese
$9.00
↳ Soup
Pasta E Fagioli
$7.00
Blistered Cherry Tomato and Spinach Soup with Tortellini
$7.00
J's Shakes & Floats
Cherry Cheesecake Shake
$8.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly Shake
$8.00
Caramel Coffee Shake
$8.00
S’mores Shake
$8.00
Manhattan Special Float
$7.00
Coconut Pineapple Shake
$8.00
Banana Walnut Shake
$8.00
Oreo Shake
$8.00
Crunchy Chocolate PB Shake
$8.00
Malted Milkshake
$7.00
Traditional Milkshake
$6.00
Cappuccino Float
$7.00
Root Beer Float
$6.00
Creamsicle Float
$6.00
Jelly Ring Milkshake
$8.00
Crunch Berry Shake
$8.00
Lucky Charms Milkshake
vanilla ice cream + fluff + rainbow marshmallows
$8.00
Cannoli Milkshake
vanilla ice cream + cannoli cream + cannoli shell + chocolate chips
$8.00
Desserts
Hershey Chocolate 🍫 Zeppoles
+ creme anglaise
$8.00
Caramel Salted Pretzel Sundae 🍨
#nomnom
$7.00
Beverages
Egg Cream
$4.00
Cappuccino
$5.00
Latte
$4.00
Espresso Double
$6.50
Espresso Macchiato
$3.50
Espresso Single
$3.00
Iced Coffee
$3.00
Orange Juice
$2.50
Apple Juice
$2.50
Cranberry Juice
$2.50
Grapefruit Juice
$2.50
Fountain Drinks
Fountain Drink Choices: Coca Cola, Sprite, Fanta Orange, Root Beer, Fruit Punch, Diet Coca Cola, Iced Tea Unsweetened and Sweetened Iced Tea
$2.00
Herbal Tea
$2.00
Coffee (Small)
Small or Large
$1.50
Coffee (Large)
Small or Large
$2.00
Cans of Soda
Choose from: Diet Coke, Coca Cola, Sprite, Orange Fanta, Gingerale, Brisk Iced Tea (sweetened)
$1.50
Regular Tea
$1.50
Bottle Water
$1.50
Manhattan Special
$3.00
Snapple
Lemon, Peach, Half n Half, Orangeade, Fruit Punch, Strawberry Kiwi, Diet Lemon, Diet Peach
$2.00
Stewart's
Black Cherry, Rootbeer, Creamsicle
$3.00
🍒 Cherry Lime Rickey
$3.50
J's T-Shirts
J's on the Bay Tees (S)
Our brand new tees are for sale right here on our website! Buy a Tee and receive 20% off your order using the promo code:
TEEOFF
$20.00
J's on the Bay Tees (M)
Our brand new tees are for sale right here on our website! Buy a Tee and receive 20% off your order using the promo code:
TEEOFF
$20.00
J's on the Bay Tees (L)
Our brand new tees are for sale right here on our website! Buy a Tee and receive 20% off your order using the promo code:
TEEOFF
$20.00
J's on the Bay Tees (XL)
Our brand new tees are for sale right here on our website! Buy a Tee and receive 20% off your order using the promo code:
TEEOFF
$20.00
J's on the Bay Tees (XXL)
Our brand new tees are for sale right here on our website! Buy a Tee and receive 20% off your order using the promo code:
TEEOFF
$20.00
Last updated August 10, 2023
Slicebest deal
$6.85
Est. Fee
20 minEst. Time
View All Deals (3)
Place Order