Order online delivery or takeout from Buttermilk Bakeshop to enjoy some of the best dessert in Brooklyn. Looking to find the cheapest way to order Buttermilk Bakeshop? Choose the most affordable,...show more
A favorite cookie dipped in Belgium chocolate
Vanilla, Lemon, Pistachio, Espresso, Chocolate, Raspberry
A selection of decadent chocolate confections for Mom!
Our favorite gift box includes a variety of chocolate covered Oreos, macarons, and Valrhona chocolate bonbons
Pick your own cookies
Pumpkin cookie with candied pecans and a maple glaze.
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream.
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream.
Red velvet cupcake with cream cheese frosting.
With cream-cheese frosting.
Chocolate Cupcake with cookie butter frosting!
GF Almond Cupcake with strawberry buttercream
A vanilla cupcake with vanilla pudding and chocolate buttercream.
With shortbread base.
Half brownie , half chocolate chunk cookie.
Chocolate vegan brownie. No Nuts or Soy
Vanilla cake with a layer of raspberry jam and vanilla buttercream. Decorates with confetti sprinkles.
6" Marble Cake soaked with espresso with mascarpone mousse filling and lady fingers and dusted in cocoa powder
Chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream. Yum.
Please contact our restaurant to ask about the flavor of the day. Flavors change on a daily basis,(347) 987 3941.
Funfetti cake with cookie and cream frosting, covered with ganache and candy
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. Serves (1-3 guests).
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream. Serves (1-3 guests).
Layers and layers of vanilla cake, buttercream and sprinkle cookie crunches! 16oz jar
Layers of chocolate cake, buttercream, crunchies and sprinkles! 16oz jar
Layers of pumpkin cake, caramel and cream cheese frosting. 16oz
Layers of vanilla cake fresh, bananas, pudding and wafer cookies! 16oz jar
Now you can bake our cookies in your home! Just scoop and bake! Bakes one dozen cookies. Bake at 350 for 12 to 14 mins. Do not consume raw cookie dough.
Now you can bake our cookies in your home! Just scoop and bake! Bakes one dozen cookies. Bake at 350 for 12 to 14 mins. Do not consume raw cookie dough.
Now you can bake our cookies in your home! Just scoop and bake! Bakes one dozen cookies. Bake at 350 for 12 to 14 mins. Do not consume raw cookie dough.
Bake at home for 10 to 12 minutes at 350F! Contains pecans.
Filled with dark, milk, and white chocolate chunks.
Rich chocolate cookie topped with nutella and sea salt.
Cinnamon sugar cookie topped with pecans and caramel.
Sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles.
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Studded with chocolate chips.
Two hazelnut shortbread cookies with raspberry jam in between.
Two pieces of red velvet cake with cannoli cream in between.
Flavors change daily. Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Flavors change daily. Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Topped with walnuts.
Flavors change daily. Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
6" (feeds 8-10). With chocolate frosting.
6" (feeds 8-10). With vanilla frosting and raspberry jam between layers.
6" (feeds 8-10). Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Choose from a variety of cakes and frostings.
Bake yummy sprinkles at home! Bake for 10 to 12 min, at 350F!
Serves 3-4 people
(Contains nuts) Chai Spice , Pecans, Caramel on top
Chocolate Chunk Cookie with Milk & Dark Chocolate
Contains nuts. Walnuts and Marshmallows on top
Contains nuts. Nutella and Sea Salt on top
Pumpkin oat cookie with white chocolate
Classic sugar cookie with sprinkles
Cinnamon cookie with maple glaze and white chocolate
Vegan and gluten free. Contains nuts.
Pumpkin cupcake with cream cheese frosting
Chocolate cupcake with cookies and cream frosting.
With cream cheese frosting.
With cream cheese frosting.
Contains nuts Chocolate cupcake with salted caramel buttercream. Caramel, peanuts , and snickers pieces on top.
Funfetti Cupcake with Cookie Butter Frosting
Gluten-free. Chocolate cupcake with chocolate and salted Nutella frosting
contains nuts
Contains nut.
Contains nuts
contains nuts Brownie with chocolate ganache. Caramel , coconut, and walnuts on top.
Orange Pecan
Chocolate ganache bar with marshmallows and graham cracker crust.
Vegan and gluten-free. Contains nuts.
Cannoli cream filling
Layers of vanilla cake, buttercream, and sprinkles.
Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, and sprinkles.
Layers of vanilla cake, buttercream and sprinkles.
Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, and sprinkles.
Serves 8 to 10 people.
Rotating flavor
Serves 8 to 10 people. Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream and a thin layer of raspberry jam.
Serves 3-4 people
Serves 12 to 15 people. Vanilla and chocolate cake with vanilla and chocolate filling.
Serves 3-4 people
Serves 8 to 10 people.
Pumpkin Pie with candied pumpkin seeds
Custard based pie with brulee
Pecan pie layered with salted nutella.
With oat crumble.
Custard based pie with burleed sugar.
Pecan pie layered with salted nutella.
Bake yummy sprinkles at home! Bake for 10 to 12 min, at 350F!
Bake yummy sprinkles at home! Bake for 10 to 12 min, at 350F!
Bake yummy sprinkles at home! Bake for 10 to 12 min, at 350F!
Last updated October 30, 2020