The Fudge Pot

Marshmallows cloaked in chocolate have a tendency to disappear Especially when added to hot drinks, Mmmm mmm.

We looked everywhere and tried different pretzels, finally we found the freshest, crunchiest, best baked salted pretzel twists. Try one and see why we drive out of state just to pick up pretzels.

Freshly roasted salted peanuts, hand covered in milk chocolate.

Fairy food, cinder toffee, honeycomb, törökméz, hokey pokey, dalgona? I had my first piece at a small candy shop in northern Michigan, so here in Old Town we're calling it Seafoam as I first learned it when I was 10 and finished that whole bag in a day. It’s a crunchy, caramelized savory confection that dissolves in your mouth as quickly as the chocolate that melts around it. Give it a try and you'll see why so many places gave it their own name and claim to be the honeycomb toffee capital of the world.

Pecans have a wonderful texture and when combined with chocolate they impart a subdued richness. We procure the best fancy Texas pecan halves and hand cloak them in chocolate.

Shredded sweetened coconut filling enrobed in rich dark chocolate.<br />

Why yes, we did make an Oreo cookie that much better. Perfect as always with a glass of milk!

For a great citrus and chocolaty taste, look no further. Fresh peels sliced, candied, and finally dipped in A distinctive balance of sweet and bitter with overtones of the natural orange aroma derived from the candied orange peel.

Whole dried and preserved apricots imported from Australia. Aged in natural cane sugar syrup, then dipped in a coating of dark chocolate.

Seedless California dark raisins, hand covered in chocolate.

Were the chocolate covered Oreos just not enough? Because these hand-dipped peanut butter cookies are irresistible.

Chicagoans have a great affection for chocolate mints. Rich, creamy, and with just a hint of mint. These classic candies are perfect for after dinner party trays and for personal indulgence.<br />

Chocolate or vanilla. Rich, cool and creamy butter creams enrobed in milk chocolate.

Chocolate cherry cordials with exquisite cherry liquor are a heavenly way to indulge yourself.

Our standard assorted box filled with everyone’s favorite goodies. Assorted almond bark, peanut butter and rum fudge balls, toffee, pretzels, raisin clusters, pecan clusters, peanut clusters, and toodles.<br />

Eight of our freshly made toodles, and one pound of our world famous butter toffee.

Available year-round, we keep gala and red delicious apples stocked Mid-September through Mid-April, and granny smith stocked Mid-April through Mid-September. Call our store to check on apple variety. <br /><br />Offered rolled in walnuts, peanuts, plain caramel. Cherry hard candy available weekends Mid-September through Mid-April or with advance phone order. Additional custom special-order options are available. Call or email us for information.<br /><br />Due to their perishable nature, apples are not available for shipping.

Made fresh daily, we hand pick our strawberries from our local produce markets to bring you the ripest, best strawberries that we can find. Available in-store in milk chocolate, dark and white chocolate are available with advance phone order. <br /><br />Due to their perishable nature, we do not ship strawberries.

Our English toffee has become one of our most popular items. Added to our offerings in 1985, Each batch is made and dipped by hand, and topped with freshly ground almonds. We assure you, one piece will never be enough.

Fudge is who we are and Fudge made our store what it is today! Every batch of fudge is hand churned in the front window of our Wells Street store using our family’s fourth-generation recipe. Come in and ask for a sample! You’re going to love our fudge.

Our fourth-generation caramel recipe cut into squares and hand dipped in chocolate, then sprinkled with Maldon Natural sea salt flakes. This is a relatively new item and has quickly become a best seller. The savory balance of sweet and salty is exquisite.

We added peanut brittle as our first product after fudge and are still using our original 1965 recipe. Made with real butter, whole salted peanuts, and just a whisper of cinnamon to make this delicious crunchy treat.

Have something to say? Say it on a sucker! Please include text for personalization and note maximum word capabilities for each size. <br /><br />Call or email for special flavor/color requests or large quantity orders. <br /><br />Due to their fragile nature, we can not ship hard candy lollipops. When picking up, please handle with care and avoid any impact on the sucker's stick. A store employee will explain handling for larger-sized suckers at pickup.

Yes, they’re Toodles. What’s a TOODLE? It’s a candy animal made from a layer of fancy Texas pecan halves, a layer of our house-made caramel, topped with a layer of milk chocolate. (not to be confused with any other chocolate caramel pecan animal)

Beautiful small batch truffles. Pick any number of flavors to make your assortment. <br /><br />Almond Coated: Amaretto<br />Plain Milk Chocolate: Rum <br />White String: Kahlúa<br />Almond Topped: Grand Marnier<br />Cinnamon Topped: Horchata<br />Coconut Flake Topped: German Chocolate

A 3-pound assortment of our best sellers toodles, almond bark, chocolate pretzels, orange peel, chocolate covered Oreos, toffee, cherry cordials, buttercreams, mints, and sea salted caramels.

A four-pound assortment of our more popular chocolates. Toodles, assorted barks, chocolate pretzels, orange peels, buttercreams, coconut joys, sea salted caramels, cherry cordials, and butter toffee.

Eight of our freshly made toodles and one pound of our world-famous butter toffee.

A five-pound assortment of our more popular chocolates. Toodles, assorted barks, chocolate covered pretzels, Oreos, hostess mints, coconut joys, buttercreams, sea salt caramels, toffee, assorted truffles, and salted mixed nuts.

Whole dried and preserved apricots imported from Australia. Aged in natural cane sugar syrup then dipped in a coating of dark chocolate.

An assortment of milk, white, and dark chocolate almond bark.

A three-dimensional gift box. The selection of assorted chocolates included filling the box.

An assortment of our more popular dark chocolate delights. Includes almond bark, pretzels, cherries, marshmallow, Kahlua truffle, salted caramels, orange peel, pecan clusters, and raisin clusters.

A one-pound box of four quarter-pound sections of our flagship product.

A 3-pound assortment of our best sellers toodles, almond bark, chocolate pretzels, orange peel, chocolate covered Oreos, toffee, cherry cordials, buttercreams, mints, and sea salted caramels.

A five-pound assortment of our more popular chocolates. Toodles, assorted barks, chocolate covered pretzels, Oreos, hostess mints, coconut joys, buttercreams, sea salt caramels, toffee, assorted truffles, and salted mixed nuts.

A four-pound assortment of our more popular chocolates. Toodles, assorted barks, chocolate pretzels, orange peels, buttercreams, coconut joys, sea salted caramels, cherry cordials, and butter toffee.

An assortment of amaretto, grand mariner, Kahlua, and rum truffles.

Our standard assorted box filled with favorite goodies. Assorted almond bark, peanut butter, and rum fudge balls, toffee, pretzels, raisin clusters, pecan clusters, peanut clusters, and toodles.

Eight of our freshly made toodles and one pound of our world-famous butter toffee.

A one-pound assortment of our more popular chocolates. Toodles, cherry cordials, almond barks, buttercreams, toffee, and a chocolate-covered Oreo.

A half-pound molded bar of chocolate. Specify milk, white, or dark chocolate for the bar.

Whole dried and preserved apricots imported from Australia. Aged in natural cane sugar syrup then dipped in a coating of dark chocolate.

An assortment of milk, white, and dark chocolate almond bark.

Chocolate or vanilla. Rich, cool, and creamy buttercreams enrobed in milk chocolate.

It is made with real butter, whole peanuts, and just a whisper of cinnamon.

Our fourth-generation caramel recipe is simply fantastic. Made in small batches and mixed by hand, our fresh caramel has the right balance of sweet to salty and shares a rich creaminess that can only be achieved from 100% natural ingredients.

Were the chocolate covered Oreos just not enough because of these hand-dipped peanut butter cookies.

Roasted salted natural whole almonds cloaked in chocolate.

Lightly salted and small-batch roasted cashews cloaked in milk chocolate. Cashews have a delicate texture and flavor that marries nicely with chocolate.

We looked everywhere and tried different pretzels, finally, we found the freshest, crunchiest, best-baked pretzel twists.

Milk chocolate and rice crispy cereal. The thickness of these bars adds to the enjoyment.

Toasted shredded coconut and milk chocolate. It is caramelized coconut flavor is delicious and the mouthfeel is a subtle crunch.

Shredded sweet coconut filling enrobed in rich dark chocolate.

Cherry cordials enrobed in milk chocolate with exquisite cherry liquor are a heavenly way to indulge yourself.

Our English toffee has become one of our most popular items. Added to our offerings in 1985, each batch is made and dipped by hand, and topped with freshly ground almonds.

Hang ten with our yummy Hawaiian delight bars. Milk chocolate, shredded coconut, macadamia nuts and you saying mahalo.

Chicagoans have a great affection for chocolate mints. Rich, creamy, and with just a hint of mint. These classic candies are perfect for after-dinner party trays and for personal indulgence.

Marshmallows cloaked in chocolate have a tendency to disappear especially when added to hot drinks.

For great citrus and chocolaty taste, look no further. Fresh peels sliced, candied, and finally dipped in a distinctive balance of sweet and bitter with overtones of the natural orange aroma derived from the all-natural candied orange peel.

Freshly roasted salted peanuts and hand covered in milk chocolate.

Pecans have a wonderful texture and when combined with chocolate they impart a subdued richness. We procure the best fancy Texas pecan halves and hand cloaks them in chocolate.

We offer milk chocolate, white chocolate, and dark chocolate.

Seedless California dark raisins and hand covered in chocolate.

It is a crunchy and caramelized savory confection that dissolves in your mouth as quickly as the chocolate that coats it.

Our fourth-generation caramel recipe cut into squares and hand-dipped in chocolate, then sprinkled with Maldon sea salt flakes. This is a relatively new item and has quickly become a best seller. The savory balance of sweet and salty is exquisite.

It is a candy animal made from a layer of fancy Texas pecan halves, a layer of our house-made caramel, and topped with a layer of milk chocolate.