10.09 mi
Sandwiches
American
American (new)
Seafood
9535 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN, 46236
Tues 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market (Pendleton Pike)
If you're looking for American (new) restaurants in Indianapolis look no further. Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market (Pendleton Pike) is known for having some of the best American (new) in Indianapolis. Located at 9535 Pendleton Pike, Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market (Pendleton Pike) is a great place to dine in or order takeout. It's the perfect option for those searching for "American (new) Near Me". They have tons of great options, so scroll down to see the Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market (Pendleton Pike) menu and pick your favorites.
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Menu
- DoorDash
Popular Items
Caplinger's Special Dinner
Two Basa fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
The Platter
One Basa fillet and ¼lb Shrimp fried or grilled along with ¼lb fried Clams and your choice of two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$17.99
Lobster Roll
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside our fresh toasted hoagie roll.
$18.99
Oyster Po Boy
Quarter pound of oysters fried and served on a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins.
$12.99
Appetizers
Calamari Fries
Tender strips of calamari breaded & fried and served with choice of sauce.
$8.99
1/2# Gator Bites
Half a pound of Alligator tail meat fried or grilled and served with choice of sauce.
$11.99
1/4# Shrimp
A quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled and served with choice of sauce.
$5.49
1/4# Fried Oysters
A quarter pound of fresh oysters breaded, fried, and served with choice of sauce.
$6.99
1/4# Clams Strips
A quarter pound of clam strips fried and served with choice of sauce.
$5.99
Clam "Chowda"
Creamy New England clam chowder.
12oz bowl.
$6.99
Crab Cake
Our house-made crab cakes are crafted with lump crab meat and just a few other fresh and simple ingredients and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.
$7.99
Sandwich Combos
Caplinger's Special Sandwich
Basa (mild, flaky whitefish) fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Catfish Sandwich
Our USA raised catfish fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Smoked Tuna Salad Sandwich
Our "almost famous" homemade smoked tuna salad served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Salmon Fillet Sandwich
Salmon fillet served grilled (or fried!) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$13.99
Lobster Roll
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside our fresh toasted hoagie roll.
$18.99
Shrimp Po Boy
A quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled and served on a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins... The usual is lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce.
$10.99
Blue Crab Melt
The ultimate indulgence, blue crab meat smothered under a blanket of melted mozzarella & provolone cheese with mayo and served on an open-faced hoagie roll.
$18.99
Oyster Po Boy
Quarter pound of oysters fried and served on a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins.
$12.99
Ocean Perch Sandwich
Ocean Perch fillets served fried on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$10.99
Whiting Sandwich
Whiting fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$10.99
Cod Sandwich
We use the loin cut of the cod making for a tasty, flaky marvel of the seafood world served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Tilapia Sandwich
Tilapia fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Chicken Breast Sandwich
A boneless, skinless chicken breast served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Calamari Steak Sandwich
Not your typical Midwesterner's sandwich. Very mild flavor and great texture make for a unique addition to the menu. Calamari Steak served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$9.99
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
An Indiana favorite, freshly cut pork tenderloin served fried (or grilled if you must) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$10.99
Dinners
Frog Legs Dinner
Half pound of frog legs fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$21.99
Lobster Roll Dinner
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside our fresh toasted hoagie roll and served with two sides & a pair of hush puppies.
$18.99
Caplinger's Special Dinner
Two Basa fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Tilapia Dinner
Two tilapia fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Fried Shrimp Dinner
A half pound of Shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$14.99
Salmon Dinner
Salmon fillet grilled (or fried) to flaky perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$14.99
Catfish Dinner
Two catfish fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Fish & Shrimp
One Basa fillet and a quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Fish & Chicken
One Basa fillet and a boneless, skinless Chicken breast fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Cod Dinner
Two Cod loin fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Alligator Tail Dinner
Half pound of Alligator Tail meat fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$17.99
Ocean Perch Dinner
Ocean Perch fillets fried to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$13.99
Whiting Dinner
Whiting fillets fried to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$10.99
Chicken Breast Dinner
Two boneless, skinless chicken breasts fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$10.99
Calamari Steak Dinner
Two tender Calamari Steaks fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$11.99
Fried Oyster Dinner
Half pound of Oysters breaded & fried to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$18.99
Crab Cake Dinner
Two tender house-made Crab Cakes baked to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$19.99
Buffalo Clam Dinner
A half pound of Clams golden fried to perfection and served with two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$13.99
The Platter
One Basa fillet and ¼lb Shrimp fried or grilled along with ¼lb fried Clams and your choice of two sides, two hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
$17.99
Kids Meal
Fish or chicken with two hush puppies, one side, and a drink.
$7.99
A la Carte Items
1# Frog Legs
1lb. frog legs.
$16.00
Single Catfish Fillet
Single fillet fried or grilled.
$4.00
Single Tilapia Fillet
Single fillet fried or grilled.
$3.50
Single Basa Fillet
Single fillet fried or grilled.
$4.00
Single Calamari Steak
Single steak fried or grilled.
$4.00
Single Chicken Breast
Single chicken breast fried or grilled.
$3.00
Single Salmon Fillet
Single fillet fried or grilled.
$7.50
Single Whiting Fillet
Single fillet fried.
$1.50
Single Cod Fillet
Single fillet fried or grilled.
$4.00
Fries
Seasoned waffle cut potatoes fried to a crispy golden brown.
$2.49
2 Perch Fillets
Two fillets fried.
$2.00
Collard Greens
Tender collard greens seasoned with smoked turkey.
$2.49
Red Beans & Rice
Red Beans & Rice seasoned with zesty andouille sausage.
$2.49
Mac & Cheese
Smooth and creamy Mac & Cheese.
$2.49
Fried Okra
Tender okra with a crisp breading fried to a golden brown.
$2.49
Hush Puppies
Delightful crusty balls of cornmeal & spices fried to a crispy golden brown.
$2.49
Green Beans
Tender green beans in a savory broth.
$2.49
Baked Beans
Hearty vegetarian baked beans in a rich BBQ sauce.
$2.49
Candied Yams
Candied yams coated with sugar & spice and everything nice.
$2.49
Chipotle Slaw
Traditional cabbage slaw in a not-so-traditional tangy chipotle slaw dressing.
$2.49
Sweet Corn with Old Bay
An Indiana favorite; juicy sweet corn sprinkled with Old Bay seasoning.
$2.49
Sweet Corn NO SEASONING
An Indiana favorite; juicy sweet corn without any fuss.
$2.49
Desserts
Key Lime Pie
Our smooth & tangy Homemade Key Lime Pie is crafted with Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice.
$3.99
Pineapple Bread Pudding
This rich & sticky homemade Pineapple Bread Pudding is drizzled with our velvety vanilla cream sauce to warm your belly. Enough to share...or not!
$4.99
Drinks
Bottled Water
23.7 fl oz Ice Mountain Spring Water w/ sport cap
$1.99
Last updated February 10, 2020
Uber EatsNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range
$0.00
Est. Fee
55 minEst. Time