Tart granny smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices.
$13.99
Boysenberry Pie
Luscious boysenberries, chock full of tangy flavor. All berries are USDA grade "A". All the berries in this pie are real boysenberries.
$13.99
PT - Whipped Cream Pie
Whipped vanilla, sugar and cream made fresh daily.
$4.29
Whole Cream Pies
Featured - Carrot Cake Mini 4 PK
$19.98
Banberry Pie
Ms. Polly's delicious banana cream filling, topped with fresh sweet strawberries and a ring of real whipped cream.
$15.99
Banana Cream Pie
Plump fresh bananas lavished in creamy vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream.
$14.49
Chocolate Cream Pie
Deep, rich chocolate, made from egg custard and cocoa, topped with real whipped cream.
$13.99
Coconut Cream Pie
The finest shredded Hawaiian coconut is drenched in rich old-fashioned custard topped with whipped cream.
$13.99
Whole Meringue & Fresh Fruit Pies
Fresh Fruit Strawberry Pie
Freshly baked pie crust topped with fresh strawberries.
$17.98
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lots of tasty lemon filling with a mountain of toasted meringue.
$12.99
Ham Feasts and Breakfast Bundles
Polly's Coffee Tote
96 oz of Polly's freshly brewed gourmet coffee in an insulated coffee tote.
$15.99
Market Place & Fixin's
QT - Polly's Red "Skin-on" Smashed Potatoes
Polly's own smashed red potatoes and mixed with cream and black pepper requires reheating.
$12.99
QT - 3 Cheese Mac
$15.99
QT - Garlic Steamed Vegs
$10.99
QT - Homestyle Stuffing
Celery and onion mixed with chicken stock and baked with our freshly baked rye, cracked wheat, and sourdough bread.
$9.99
QT - Beef Gravvy
Creamy beef stock with tomato, onion and garlic.
$6.99
PT - Zesty Cranberry Sauce
Cranberries, orange marmalade, and sugars simmered to perfection.
$3.99
Ham Glaze 6 oz
Brown sugar combined with dijon mustard and honey sauce.
$2.99
Whole Pies No Sugar Added
Apple Pie No Sugar Added
Tart granny with smith apples, delicately flavored with our own special blend of spices and equal sugar substitute.
$14.99
Bakery to Go
Carrot Cake Muffin 4 Pack
$10.99
Cinnamon Roll 2 Pack
Ms. Polly's own giant cinnamon rolls baked fresh in the big red oven.
$4.99
Loaf Kracked Wheat
Kracked wheat bread baked fresh in the big red oven.
$5.99
Loaf-Rye
Rye bread baked fresh in the big red oven.
$4.99
Loaf-White
White bread baked fresh in the big red oven.
$4.99
Loaf-Raisin Walnut
Raisin walnut baked fresh in the big red oven.
$6.99
Loaf-Sourdough
Sourdough bread baked fresh in the big red oven.
$4.99
15 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Yummy cookies baked with coach's oats and raisins in the big red oven.
$9.49
15 Chocolate Chip Cookies
Polly's signature chocolate chip cookies baked fresh in the big red oven.
$9.49
Blueberry Muffin 4 Pack
Four-pack of blueberry muffins of baked fresh in the big red oven.
$6.49
Bran Muffin 4 Pack
Four pack of bran muffins with walnut and raisins baked fresh in the big red oven.
$6.49
Cornbread Pan
Cornbread baked fresh from the big red oven in a pie tin.
$4.99
Dozen Freshly Baked Dinner Rolls
Dinner rolls baked fresh in the big red oven.
$4.99
Pie Shell
Our famous pie crust, frozen and ready to bake.
$3.49
Pie Shell 3 Pack
Three pack of our famous pie crust, frozen and ready to bake.
$8.99
St. Patrick's Day Specials
Reuben Sandwich
Tender grilled seasoned corn beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and o'Polly's special sauce on freshly baked, toasted rye bread. Served with "made from scratch" Kona style chips.
Chicken fried steak, country gravy, garlic steamed vegetables, smashed potatoes and chicken gravy.
$49.99
Whole Chicken Pie Family Dinner
The whole chicken pie baked in Ms. Polly's famous pie crust. A quart of chicken gravy, a quart of red skin-on smashed potatoes, 8 oz cranberry sauce, and a dozen dinner rolls. Feeds four or more.
$32.99
Whole Chicken Pie
Tender lean light chicken, simmered in a savory gravy with a hearty combination of broccoli, celery, cauliflower, carrots, peas, sweet onions, and potatoes all baked in our famous pie crust. Includes 1 pint of chicken gravy and 8 oz cranberry sauce.
$23.99
Whole Caramalized Onion Quiche
Swiss cheese, mushrooms, hashbrowns, caramelized onions, and red bell peppers, in an egg filling, baked in Polly's old fashioned deep dish crust.
$17.98
Last updated October 19, 2020
Uber EatsNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range