Order online delivery or takeout from Mr. Dye's Pies to enjoy some of the best dessert in Milwaukee.
Looking to find the cheapest way to order Mr. Dye's Pies? Choose the most affordable, or the q...show more
Menus
Pies
Classic Sweet Potato
$16.00
Pecan Delight
$20.00
Key Lime Pie
$22.00
Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$22.00
Nawlin's Pecan
$22.00
Half Pies
Classic Sweet Potato
$8.00
Pecan Delight
$10.00
Key Lime Pie
$11.00
Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$11.00
Nawlin's Pecan
$11.00
Pie Slice
Classic Sweet Potato
$4.00
Pecan Delight
$4.00
Nawlin's Pecan
$4.00
Key Lime Pie
$4.00
Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$4.00
Popular Items
N'awlins Pecan
$20.00
Fun take on a traditional southern pecan pie.
Half Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$13.00
We use a generous amount of brandy and light it on fire to leave you with a smooth brandy flavor and give your Wisconsin Classic cocktail in a cherry pie you have to taste to believe!.
Half Pie - Classic Sweet Potato
$8.00
The best sweet potato pie on Earth.
Key Lime Pie
$22.00
Pecan Delight
$20.00
Classic sweet potato pie with a pecan topping.
Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$22.00
Purple Monster
$20.00
Sweet potato pie made with an Okinawan purple yam.
Dessert
Classic
$16.00
Sweet potato pie.
Pecan Delight
$20.00
Classic sweet potato pie with a pecan topping.
N'awlins Pecan
$20.00
Fun take on a traditional southern pecan pie.
Key Lime Pie
$22.00
Purple Monster
$20.00
Sweet potato pie made with an Okinawan purple yam.
Purple Monster with Pecans
$22.00
Sweet potato pie made with an Okinawan purple yam.
Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$22.00
Half Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry Pie
$13.00
We use a generous amount of brandy and light it on fire to leave you with a smooth brandy flavor and give your Wisconsin Classic cocktail in a cherry pie you have to taste to believe!.
Half Pie - Classic Sweet Potato
$8.00
The best sweet potato pie on Earth.
Water
$1.00
water
$1.00
water
$1.00
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)
Uber EatsNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range