Order from Bethel Bakery and you're ordering from a bakery that is one of the most well-liked in Bethel Park.
And your order from Bethel Bakery will be a great deal too when you select the most a...show more
Menu
Gormet Pies
Apple Half Pie
$18.45
Baked to a golden brown, delicious apple pie is turned upside down to let the sweetness of honey enrobe it. The finishing touch of creamy caramel and pecans on top make this pie a holiday favorite!
Apple Half Pie
$6.45
Half Pie
$7.25
Apple Pie
$10.90
Apple Walnut Pie
$16.45
Cookies
Candy Corn Cookies
$250.00
Iced shortbread.
Pumpkin Shortbread Cookies
$4.50
Per dozen.
Half-Dipped Shortbread Pumpkins Cookies
$5.00
Per dozen.
Jimmy Shortbread Daisy Cookies
$4.00
Per dozen.
Chocolate Button Cookies
$5.00
Per dozen. Button colors change seasonally.
Novelty Cakes
Teapot Cake
$98.50
Serves 25, 9-inch triple-layer cake.
Lego Cake - Small
$38.50
Serves 16.
Lego Cake - Large
$56.50
Serves 30 - 36.
Hoagie & Chips
$73.50
Serves 16.
Poppyseed Bagel
$54.25
Serves 16, 9 inch cake iced with buttercream and topped with real poppyseeds.
Coffee Cakes
Hot Cross Buns
$5.49
Traditional sweet dough with raisins and glazed cherries. Topped with a tasty icing cross.
Cinnamon Danish Cluster
$6.95
An old fashioned cinnamon coffeecake made of danish dough, a moist cinnamon filling and topped with crunchy cinnamon sugar.
Danish Tea Ring
$6.95
A coffeecake made of our deliciously rich and flaky danish dough and topped with our fondant icing. A danish purist delight.
Edelweiss
$6.95
A popular danish coffeecake with custard baked in for extra moistness. Chopped pecans and sugar are added on top for a mouth-watering combination suitable anytime.
Fruit Twirls
$6.95
A danish coffee cake with an apricot or cherry filling swirled so you have both danish dough and filling in every bite.
Bread & Rolls
Bethel Bakery Pepperoni Rolls
$3.37
Marble Bread
$4.30
Breadworks. Whole loaf.
Whole Wheat Bread
$4.30
Breadworks. Whole loaf.
White Pullman Bread
$3.89
Breadworks. This square white bread is the perfect size for the sandwich and toaster. Whole loaf.
Rye Bread
$4.30
Breadworks. Whole loaf.
Jumbo Muffins Breakfast Rolls
Jumbo Muffins Roll
$1.45
Apricot Cups Roll
$1.10
Served with apricot filling is layered to the sweet dough and formed like a cupcake. Fondant icing tops off this breakfast treat.
Fruit Danish Roll
$1.39
Comes with rich and flaky danish dough is used to make these rolls. The oval shape allows a generous amount of apple, apricot, cheese, blueberry, cherry or pineapple filling in every bite.
Nut Rolls
$1.10
A single size version of nut ring coffeecake, a generous amount of nut filling is layered into a sweet dough.
Pecan Roll
$2.25
This large-sized breakfast roll has our moist cinnamon filling in the sweet dough. Topped off with whole pecans and the honey glaze makes this great alone or warmed with butter.
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)
PostmatesNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range