Order from Bay 1 Ice Cream Parlor & Sandwich Shop to enjoy some of the best Tea in Indian Shores.
Looking to find the cheapest way to order Bay 1 Ice Cream Parlor & Sandwich Shop? Choose the most...show more
Menu
Savory Sandwiches
9" Pressed Authentic Cuban Sandwich
$10.99
Authentically made Cuban Sandwich. Savory Pulled Pork, Smoked Ham, Salami, Swiss Cheese and Pickle, covering freshly baked Cuban bread pressed to perfection.
9" Pressed Cuban Pulled Pork Sandwich
$10.99
Savory pulled pork covering authentic Cuban bread pressed to perfection.
9" Pressed Cuban Reuben Pulled Pork Sandwich
$10.99
Savory pulled pork, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing, covering freshly baked Cuban bread pressed to perfection.
Old Fashioned Premium Ice Cream
Pint
$8.99
Your choice of one of our premium flavors.
The Big Dipper
$6.99
Delicious Yoder's Premium Ice Cream. Pick up to 3 flavors.
Couples Pint
$15.99
Your choice of one of our premium flavors per pint.
The Little Dipper
$4.84
Delicious Yoder's Premium Ice Cream. Pick up to 2 flavors.
It's a Party Trifecta Pint
$21.99
Your choice of one of our premium flavors per pint.
Shake It Up
Shakes (20 oz)
$7.99
Root Beer Float (20 oz)
$7.99
Diet Coke Float (20 oz)
$7.99
Malts (20 oz)
$7.99
Coke Float (20 oz)
$7.99
Quenchers
20 oz Sprite
$2.99
12 oz A&W Root Bear
$1.99
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)
Uber EatsNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range