Captain Cookie and the Milkman

This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years.

Chewy, puffy cookies with dark molasses flavor, spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and lots of ginger. Crowned with sugar for a crispy crust!

Our version of the chocolate lover's classic is rich, fudgey, and loaded with dark chocolate.

Our special twist on the classic peanut butter. It’s gooey, with honey vanilla notes, and chock full of peanut butter!

Guaranteed to take you back to childhood with one bite. Our snickerdoodles are buttery, tender, and rolled in cinnamon sugar, just like Mom did.

The classic. Chewy oats with just the right level of spice and a generous helping of plump raisins.

The Captain churns our vegan butter from scratch, these cookies are a three-day process, and their amazing taste is the result of years of recipe-tweaking!

Choose 12 cookies.

Choose 6 cookies.

Please specify your selection of 13 cookies in "special instructions" options include: chocolate chip, vegan chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, funfetti, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, ginger molasses and double chocolate chip.

Please specify your selection of six cookies in "special instructions" options include: chocolate chip, vegan chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, funfetti, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, ginger molasses and double chocolate chip.

Vegan.

Vanilla ice cream sandwich. Please choose what you want your top and bottom cookies to be.

Ice cream from a local creamery.

One bottle of milk plus two cookies of your choice.