The sarge’s mild buffalo pub sauce, spicy Lambo sauce, wing sauce of the month. Served with choice of carrots or celery, ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
$7.25
Combination Basket
A tasty helping of our favorite apps - chicken strips, onion rings, and cheese curds served with weakness sauce.
$9.94
Stuffed Mushrooms
Succulent crab-stuffed mushroom buttons broiled and topped with gooey provolone cheese.
$8.85
Quesadilla
Vegetarian-friendly items. A large flour tortilla grilled with tomato, green onion, jalapeño, and cheddar Jack cheese. Served with a side of our house-made fiesta sauce.
$8.05
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
The sarge’s creamy recipe, topped with grated romano cheese and served with your choice of warm French bread slices or crunchy tortilla chips.
$8.85
Preston’s Hot Wing Dip
Our one-of-a-kind spicy Lambo sauce blended with cream cheeses shredded chicken and green onions. Served with tortilla chips.
$8.35
Potato Skins
Hollowed Idaho potatoes smothered with shredded cheddar-Jack cheese, crispy bacon bits, and green onions. Served with a side of sour cream.
$8.05
Crab Cakes
Crab rounds, grilled to golden perfection. Served with the sarge’s fiesta sauce.
$8.85
Nacho Plate
Crunchy tortilla rounds piled high with shredded cheese, jalapeño peppers, black olives, green onions, tomatoes and your choice of meat. Served with salsa and sour cream.
$9.94
Cheese & Vegetable Plate
Freshly cut vegetables and cheese cubes served with ranch dressing.
$8.35
Cheese Curds
A Canadian favorite, golden fried and served with weakness sauce.
$8.05
Chicken Strips
Juicy chicken tenders served with a side of our signature weakness sauce.
$8.85
Clam Strips
A hearty helping of tasty clam strips goldenly fried to perfection and served with cocktail sauce.
$8.05
Soups
Brisket Chili Soup
Our own award-winning recipe of hearty beef brisket and chili mixings.
$4.75
Soup of the Day
$4.75
Cool Greens
Garden Salad
Vegetarian-friendly items. Fresh salad mix with tomato, green onion, celery, cucumber, mushroom, and radish.
$5.85
Chef Salad
Garden salad, shredded cheddar-Jack cheese, ham, turkey, and egg slices.
$8.85
Grilled Chicken Salad
Garden salad, shredded mozzarella cheese and your choice of chicken: plain, buffalo, spicy lambo, teriyaki, cajun or make it crispy.
$8.85
Taco Salad
Fresh salad mix topped with green onion, tomato, shredded cheddar-Jack cheese, sour cream and your choice of chicken or spicy Mexican beef. Served with tortilla chips.
$8.85
Black & Bleu Salad
A bed of romaine lettuce topped with thin-sliced new york strip, tomato, green onion, mushroom, and bleu cheese crumbles. Served with bleu cheese dressing.
$10.29
Rotini Pasta Salad
Vegetarian-friendly items. Tri-colored pasta with tomatoes, cucumbers, and grated romano cheese.
$8.35
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with Parmesan cheese, egg beaters, cracked pepper, anchovies, grated romano cheese, and the sarge’s Caesar dressing.
$8.85
Hot Sammies
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Served with steak fries. An Indiana staple hand-cut, tenderized and served on a brioche bun - choose grilled or breaded.
$9.15
Steak Sandwich
Served with steak fries. Our hand-cut ribeye steak chargrilled and served on a French roll.
$11.05
French Dip Sammies
Served with steak fries. Thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a fresh French roll served with a side of house-made au jus.
$9.44
Reuben Sammies
Served with steak fries. A mountain of your choice of lean corned beef or juicy turkey meat topped with 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread.
$9.44
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Served with steak fries. Buffalo, spicy Lambo, teriyaki, cajun or plain.
$9.15
Spinach & Artichoke Chicken Sandwich
Served with steak fries. Our savory chicken breast smothered under our spinach & artichoke dip and melted provolone cheese on grilled sourdough bread.
$10.85
Preston’s Club Sammies
Served with steak fries. Join the club with a triple-decker of deli ham, turkey and crispy bacon on toasted sourdough with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$9.44
Turkey Supreme Sammies
Served with steak fries. Deli turkey piled high with avocado, cucumber, sprouts, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bread.
$9.44
Grilled Veggie Sandwich
A bed of fresh cucumbers, sprouts, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and mushroom on your choice of grilled sourdough, 12-grain or light rye bread.
$8.60
Grilled Cheese Sammies
Vegetarian-friendly items. Served with steak fries. The sarge’s go-to cold weather fix - two choices of cheese melted between your choice of grilled bread.
$8.05
Tuna Melt Sammies
Served with steak fries. Fresh tuna salad, served on grilled sourdough with your choice of cheese.
$9.15
Cold Sammies
BLT Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Chicken Salad Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Ham Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Roast Beef Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Turkey Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Tuna Salad Sammies
Served on sourdough or wheat bread, with potato chips and a dill spear.
$8.05
Burgers
The Preston Burger
Served with steak fries. Our pride and joy - our house specialty half-pound certified Angus beef.
$9.75
Canadian Burger
Served with steak fries. Canadian bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and weakness sauce.
$10.85
Black & Bleu Burger
Served with steak fries. Blackened seasoning, grilled mushrooms, and bleu cheese crumbles.
$10.55
Jammin’ Jalapeño Burger
Served with steak fries. Smoked gouda cheese, crispy bacon, and savory jalapeño jam.
$11.05
Patty Melt Burger
Served with steak fries. Melted Swiss cheese and grilled onions served hot on grilled rye.
$10.85
Lafayette’s Original Buffalo Burger
Served with steak fries. 1/3 lb of 100% juicy ground bison.
$10.85
Wraps & Tacos
Fiesta Wrap
Served with cottage cheese. Preston’s favorite. Our juicy cajun chicken breast sliced and tossed with cheddar-Jack cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, green onion, and secret fiesta sauce.
$9.15
Grilled Chicken BLT Wrap
Served with cottage cheese. Our juicy grilled chicken breast tossed with bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, cheddar-Jack cheese, and creamy ranch dressing.
$9.15
Steak Wrap
Served with cottage cheese. Grilled New York strip, sliced and tossed with shredded cheddar-Jack cheese, grilled onion, and green pepper. Served with the sarge’s fiesta sauce.
$9.94
Pulled Pork Tacos
Served with cottage cheese. Our own delectable creation - three soft taco shells piled high with tender pulled pork, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, green onion, and creamy white bbq sauce.
$8.35
Preston’s Tacos
Served with cottage cheese. Three soft taco shells stuffed with shredded lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese, a side of salsa and sour cream.
$8.05
Dinner Delights
New York Strip
Thick, 14 oz New York strip, hand-cut, trimmed and chargrilled to your liking.
$25.49
Ribeye
Tender, marbled 14 oz choice ribeye, hand-cut, trimmed and grilled to your liking.
$25.49
Grilled Chicken
Plain, cajun, teriyaki, buffalo or spicy lambo. Served on a steamy bed of wild rice.
$17.69
Smothered Chicken
Choice of chicken smothered with Provolone cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers.
$18.05
Center-Cut Pork Loin Chop
Juicy center-cut, butterflied loin, served with a side of tasty applesauce.
$19.14
Salmon Filet
Fresh, grilled salmon smothered with a cilantro lime glaze.
$20.25
Catfish Filet
Two hearty filets coated in a cornmeal breading, golden fried and served with tartar sauce and lemon wedges.
$18.05
House-Made Stuffed Shrimp
Large shrimp stuffed with tender crab meat, bread crumbs, herbs and spices, coated with a buttery glaze then broiled to perfection.
$23.25
Signature Sides & Sauces
Coleslaw
$2.19
Cottage Cheese
$2.19
Side Salad
$2.19
Applesauce
$2.19
Steamed Veggie of the Day
$3.65
Wild Rice
$3.65
Garlic Toast
$1.95
Onion Rings
$5.85
Preston’s Fries
$4.19
The Sarge’s Sauces
$0.55
Sweets
Preston’s Homemade Bread Puddin’
A person's tradition - topped with our sticky whiskey sauce and whipped topping.