About Brother Jimmy's BBQ
If you're looking for Southern restaurants in New York look no further. Brother Jimmy's BBQ is known for having some of the best Southern in New York. Located at 181 Lexington Ave, Brother Jimmy'...show more
Menus
Served with salsa and sour cream. Available with protein for an additional charge.
Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado and onion. Available with protein for an additional charge.
Pulled pork and slaw. Our signature sandwich for 30 years.
Choose one of your favorites!
Smoked low and slow for 14 hours
Fried Chicken, Jalapeno Jack Cheese Sauce, Onion Ring
8 oz. Custom Brother Jimmy's beef blend burger, served with lettuce, tomato, and topped with Onion Ring and choice of Cheddar or Swiss cheese
Plant based burger served with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, and topped with choice of Swiss or Cheddar cheese and Chipotle BBQ sauce
Boston Butt Smoked for 12 hours. Brother Jimmy’s Carolina Clear BBQ Sauce.
Boston Butt Smoked for 12 hours. Brother Jimmy’s Carolina Clear BBQ Sauce.
Brother Jimmy’s Original BBQ Sauce.
Brother Jimmy’s Original BBQ Sauce.
'Fall off the bone' St. Louis style pork ribs. Available wet, dry or combo.
Our beloved Brother Jimmy’s Competition Winning Black Angus Brisket. Smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood.
Our beloved Brother Jimmy’s Competition Winning Black Angus Brisket. Smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood.
Custom southern blend mac and cheese. Add your choice of BBQ.
Custom southern blend mac and cheese. Add your choice of BBQ.
Half a chicken (4 pieces) with 1 side.
Wings, and your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken, and 1 side.
Wings, and your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken, and 1 side.
Wings, and your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken, and 1 side.
Wings, and your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken, and 1 side.
Pulled pork, pulled chicken, and 2 sides.
Pulled pork, pulled chicken, and 2 sides.
Pulled pork, pulled chicken, and 2 sides.
Pulled pork, pulled chicken, and 2 sides.
1 Starter, 2 mains, and 2 sides.
1 Starter, 2 mains, and 2 sides.
1 Starter, 2 mains, and 2 sides.
1 Starter, 2 mains, and 2 sides.
2 Starters, 3 mains, and 3 sides.
2 Starters, 3 mains, and 3 sides.
2 Starters, 3 mains, and 3 sides.
2 Starters, 3 mains, and 3 sides.
Serves 6. All the BBQ and fixins’ you need for a perfect picnic spread: 1 lb Pulled Pork, 1 lb Brisket, 1 Pounds of Wet Ribs, 1 pound of Dry Ribs – 1 Bucket of Wings -- 1 quart Mac & Cheese -- 1 quart Coleslaw -- 6 Cornbread Muffins 4 oz BJ ORIGINAL Bbq Sauce, 4 oz. BJ CHIPOTLE Bbq Sauce, 4 oz. BJ CAROLINA Bbq Sauce Picnic ready with plates & utensils - no substitutions.
Smoked over Hickory wood for 12 hours. Served in 1 piece. (4-5 pounds) Refrigerated.
Smoked low and slow for 16 hours in our ol' hickory smoker. 5-6 pounds. Refrigerated.
Served with horseradish sauce.
Bourbon maple syrup.
A variety of appetizers to enjoy alone or share with a group. Served with maple butter.
A variety of appetizers to enjoy alone or share with a group. Served with homemade tortilla chips.
A variety of appetizers to enjoy alone or share with a group. Served with homemade blue cheese.
Pork shoulder slow smoked and pulled with brother jimmy's Carolina BBQ. Served with one side and pickles.
Certified black Angus brisket smoked for up to 14 hours, lean or marbled. Served with one side and pickles.
Smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with one side and pickles.
Brisket blended half pound burger topped with pulled pork and BBQ sauce.
Fried chicken, jalapeno Jack cheese, and onion rings.
Cheddar, onion rings, and bourbon BBQ sauce.
Turkey burger, Swiss cheese, grilled onions, and chipotle mayonnaise.
Avocado, tomato, smoked turkey, shredded lettuce, and honey mustard.
Original BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Pressed and Melted on Texas toast.
Grilled portobello, Swiss, marinated peppers, and balsamic vinegar.
Our BBQ beef and pork sloppy joe.
Brisket blended half pound burger topped with fried onion, Cheddar cheese, and onion rings with chipotle BBQ sauce.
Slow smoked pulled pork with creamy cheese sauce.
Pork shoulder slow smoked and pulled with brother jimmy's Carolina BBQ. served with one side, cornbread and pickles.
Served with tomato tartar sauce.
Brother Jimmys sweet BBQ sauce.
Blue cheese and lettuce.
Served with pickle.
Three per order.
Coleslaw and pickle.
Pickles.
Original BBQ sauce.
Roasted corn salsa.
Grilled pineapple slaw.
Grilled pineapple slaw.
BJ burger, lettuce, tomato, cheese, cucumber, pickles, scallions, bacon and special sauce.
Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado, and onion.
Romaine with cornbread croutons and homemade Caesar dressing.
Baby kale, shredded Brussels sprouts, pecorino cheese and lemon vinaigrette.
Been serving these since brother jimmy’s opened in 1989. fried dill pickles were popularized by Bernell "Fatman" Austin in 1963 at the duchess drive-in located in Atkins, Arkansas.[1][2][3] the Fatman's recipe is only known to his family and used once each year at the annual pickle fest in Atkins, held each May.
Bourbon maple syrup.
Been serving these since brother jimmy’s opened in 1989. the name is often attributed to the civil war, in which Confederate soldiers are said to have tossed fried cornbread to quell the barks of their dogs.
Tortilla chips.
Blue cheese.
Brisket blended half pound burger topped with pulled pork and BBQ sauce.
Fried chicken, jalapeno Jack cheese, and onion rings.
Cheddar, onion rings, and bourbon BBQ sauce.
Turkey burger, Swiss cheese, grilled onions, and chipotle mayonnaise.
Avocado, tomato, smoked turkey, shredded lettuce, and honey mustard.
Original BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Pressed and Melted on Texas toast.
Grilled portobello, Swiss, marinated peppers, and balsamic vinegar.
Our BBQ beef and pork sloppy joe.
Brisket blended half pound burger topped with fried onion, Cheddar cheese, and onion rings with chipotle BBQ sauce.
Slow smoked pulled pork and creamy cheese sauce.
Served with tomato tartar sauce.
Blue cheese and lettuce.
Served with pickle.
Coleslaw and pickle.
Pickles
Original BBQ sauce.
Roasted corn salsa.
Grilled pineapple slaw.
Grilled pineapple slaw.
Bj burger, lettuce, tomato, cheese, cucumber, onions, bacon, and special sauce.
Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado, and onion.
Romaine with cornbread croutons and Caesar dressing.
Baby kale, Brussel sprouts, tomatoes, almonds, pecorino cheese, and balsamic vinegar.
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Last updated April 12, 2021