Order online delivery or takeout from Buttermilk Bake Shop to enjoy some of the best dessert in Brooklyn.
Looking to find the cheapest way to order Buttermilk Bake Shop? Choose the most affordabl...show more
Menu
Menu
Spiced Hot Chocolate Cookies
$2.75
With cayenne and paprika.
Cookies
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$2.75
Filled with dark, milk, and white chocolate chunks.
Cookie of the Day
$2.75
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Vegan Gingersnap Cookie
$2.75
Salted Nutella Cookie
$2.75
Rich chocolate cookie topped with nutella and sea salt.
Chai Spice Pecan Snickerdoodle Cookie
$2.75
Chai spice sugar cookie topped with pecans and caramel.
Butterscotch Marshmallow Cookie
$2.75
Peanut Butter Cookie
$2.75
Black and White Cookie
$2.75
Build Your Own 6-Pack Cookie
$16.50
Sprinkle Cookie
$2.75
Sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles.
Build Your Own 4-Pack Cookie
$11.00
Build Your Own 12-Pack Cookie
$30.00
V/GF Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$2.75
Vegan & Gluten Free
Bars
Lemon Bar
$3.00
Fudge Brownie Bar
$3.00
Loaded with chocolate chips.
Vegan Fudge brownie
$3.00
Vegan chocolate brownie with chocolate chips
Cherry Pie Bar
$3.00
Cherry Pie Filling, with almond crumb
Rasberry Rose Cheesecake
$3.00
Raspberry Cheesecake with rose petals and a touch of cream cheese buttercream
Cupcakes
Vanilla Cupcake
$2.75
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
4-Pack Cupcake
$11.00
Red Velvet Cupcake
$11.00
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.
Dozen Cupcakes
$30.00
6-Pack Cupcake
$16.50
Chocolate Cupcake
$11.00
With chocolate buttercream. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
Daily Cupcake
$2.75
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information. Available in packs of 4, 6, or one dozen.
GF Chocolate Cupcake
$2.75
Chocolate and Nutella buttercream
Mango Chamoy Cupcake
$3.00
Vanilla Cupcake with Mango swiss buttercream , coconut flakes, chamoy
Tutti Frutti Cupcake
$2.75
Funfetti cupcake with citrus buttercream and Frutti white chocolate!
Cookie Butter Cupcake
$2.75
Chocolate cupcake with speculoos buttercream and cookie crumbles
Other Desserts
Cake Pops
$7.00
Flavors change daily. Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Gluten Free Banana Bread Loaf
$20.00
Topped with walnuts.
Macarons
$2.00
Flavors change daily. Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
Buttery Shortbread
$1.00
Lemon shortbread with poppy seeds
Homemade Milano Cookie
$3.00
Buttery Milano cookies with citrus ganache in-between
Cakes & Party Packs
Custom Cake
$36.00
Choose from a variety of cakes and frostings. Pre-order 48 hours before delivery
Vanilla Cake
$36.00
6" (feeds 8-10). With vanilla frosting and raspberry jam between layers.
Chocolate Cake
$36.00
6" (feeds 8-10). With chocolate frosting.
Daily Cake
$45.00
6" (feeds 8-10). Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
10" Cake of the Day
$60.00
10" [ serves 18-25] please call 347-987-3941 for details
Pies
Nutella Pecan Pie
$32.00
Buttermilk Pie
$30.00
Bake At Home Cookie Dough
Gluten-Free / Vegan Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough
$12.00
Contains almond flour , no soy
Sugar Cookie Kits
Candy Filled Cupcakes
$19.00
Fill and decorate six cupcakes, with candy inside and buttercream frosting on top! In the kit you get three vanilla cupcakes, three chocolate cupcakes with vanilla and chocolate buttercream. Plus toppings!!
Breakfast
Crossant
$2.75
Classic Croissant
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)
Uber EatsNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range