Pick A Bagel
About Pick A Bagel
Order online delivery or takeout from Pick A Bagel to enjoy some of the best bagels in New York. Looking to find the cheapest way to order Pick A Bagel? Choose the most affordable, or the quickes...show more
Menus
Served with a bagel, butter and home fries.
Served with a bagel, butter and home fries.
Served with a bagel, butter and home fries.
Ham, bell peppers and onions.
Ham, bell peppers and onions. Served with a bagel, butter and home fries.
Onions, bell peppers and tomatoes.
Onions, bell peppers and tomatoes. Served with a bagel, butter and home fries.
Mushrooms, broccoli and bell peppers.
Mushrooms, broccoli and bell peppers.
Smoked salmon and Bermuda onions.
Smoked salmon and Bermuda onions.
2 Eggs, 2 pancakes, 2 bacon strips and 2 sausage patties.
Egg-white, spinach, mushrooms, avocado and Swiss cheese
Egg with avocado, scallion, Jack cheese and tomatoes.
Egg, ham, tomatoes, onions, peppers and cheddar cheese.
Bacon, egg, cheese, homefries.
Tomato, onions, pepper-jack cheese, avocado.
13 bagels.
Smoked turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a sesame bagel.
Homestyle tuna salad, cheddar, lettuce, tomato on a multi-grain bagel.
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella on a plain bagel.
Honey roasted turkey, toasted turkey, avocado, Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a sesame bagel.
Your choice of pastrami or corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, mustard and mayonnaise on a poppyseed bagel.
Homestyle chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion on a poppyseed bagel.
Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a plain bagel. Additional charge to add avocado.
Black forest ham, honey glazed turkey, Swiss cheese, sharp cheddar, tomatoes, and greens with honey Dijon dressing on an everything bagel.
Portobello mushrooms, sprouts, avocado, tomatoes, with balsamic vinaigrette on a sesame bagel.
13 bagels.
Sliced nova, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion, avocado, capers.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions.
Sliced nova, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion, avocado, capers. Served with a bagel.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Available in quarter pound increments.
Non-fat yogurt, bananas, strawberries, orange juice and protein powder.
Non-fat yogurt, mango, banana, pineapple juice and protein powder.
Non-fat yogurt, bananas, honey, peanut butter, skim milk and protein powder.
Raspberries, strawberries, mango and apple juice.
Raspberries, strawberries, blueberries and apple juice.
Strawberries, bananas, apple juice.
Blueberries, banana, strawberries and apple juice.
Mango, pineapple, banana and apple juice.
Mango, baby spinach, banana and orange juice.
Chocolate.
Served with Home-Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread.
Made with broccoli, mushrooms & bell peppers. Served with home fried or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Made with Feta cheese, Kalamata olives & Beef Stake tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Made with Bermuda Onions, Bell Peppers & Diced Tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Made with sharp Vermont cheddar, Jarlsberg Swiss Cheese & American Cheese. Served with home fries or lettuce and tomatoes Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Made with Nova Scotia Salmon,Eggs & Bermuda Onions served with Home Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread.
One Egg, One Pancake, One Sausage Patty, One Bacon Strip.
2 Eggs, 2 Pancakes, 2 Sausage Patties, 2 Bacon Strips.
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Served with crisp lettuce, Holland tomatoes, Bermuda Onion & home-made coleslaw.
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Build Your Own Sandwich.
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucumbers, Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce.
Includes all 4 of the above.
Oven roasted turkey, Artichoke, Tomato, Mixed baby greens, & Artichoke pesto.
Smoked Turkey, Avocado, Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, mayo & drizzled EVOO. Recommended on plain bagel.
Oven roasted chicken breast, crispy bacon, swiss cheese, mixed baby greens, & light mayonnaise. Recommended on rustic square.
Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, melted fresh mozzarella, & basil pesto aioli. Recommended on ciabatta.
Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, & creamy herbed mayonnaise. Recommended on rustic square.
Black forest ham, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, plum tomatoes, romaine lettuce & garlic aioli. Recommended on country sourdough.
Black forest ham, honey glazed turkey, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Vermont cheddar cheese, romaine lettuce & honey dijon spread. Recommended on sesame bagel.
Hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese, spicy mustard & garlic aioli. Recommended on seeded rye.
Hot corned beef, melted muenster cheese, sauerkraut, spicy golden mustard. Recommended on seeded rye.
Hot roast beef, Vermont cheddar, caramelized onions, romaine lettuce, beefsteak tomatoes & Russian dressing. Recommended on a sesame bagel.
Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, & light mayonnaise. Recommended on country sour dough.
Hard salami, black forest ham, provolone cheese, romaine Lettuce, Beefsteak tomatoes, artichoke pesto & EVOO. Recommended on rustic square.
Home-style tuna salad, melted vermont cheddar, mixed baby greens, & plum tomato. Recommended on hearty multi-grain bread.
Portobello mushrooms, avocado, sprouts, plum tomatoes, fresh goat cheese & creamy balsamic vinaigrette. Recommended on plain bagel.
Home-made egg salad, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, kosher salt, & cracked black pepper. Recommended on a everything bagel.
Fresh made mozzarella, plum tomatoes, roasted red peppers & basil pesto spread. Recommended on rustic square.
Chopped Romaine lettuce tossed together with roasted turkey, avocado, tomato, pepper jack cheese, Bermuda onions, and crunchy tri-color tortilla chips with a tangy chipotle lime vinaigrette.
Same as an Taste Of Greece Salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.
Same as a Cali Cobb chopped salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.
Same as Asian Chopped Salad but rolled up into a whole wheat wrap.
Grilled Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Kidney Beans, Crispy Tortillas, Pepper Jack Cheese, Jalapenos & Baby Spinach Leaves. Tossed with Tangy Chipolte Dressing.
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, pecornio Romano, kalamata olives, croutons, hard boiled egg and creamy garlic Caesar dressing.
Same as South Beach chopped salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.
Non fat yogurt, low fat granola and fresh berries.
Ham, bacon or sausage.
Ham, bacon or sausage.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. Mushrooms, brocolli, and bell peppers.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. Ham, peppers, and onions.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. Spinach, Kalamata olives, tomatoes, and feta.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. Onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. American, Cheddar, and Swiss.
Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries. Smoked salmon and Bermuda onions.
With brown sugar.
Choice of Bagel
Please choose your variety
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel.
Choice of Salad Spread
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Choice of Bagel
Non fat yogurt, low fat granola, and fresh berries.
Includes any bagel with butter.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Quarter LB.
Hot pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, spicy mustard, and garlic aioli.
Hot corned beef, sauerkraut, melted muenster, and spicy mustard.
Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, greens, beefsteak tomatoes, and light mayo.
Hot roast beef, sharp Cheddar, onions, greens, beefsteak tomatoes, and Russian dressing.
Salami, ham, provolone cheese, greens, tomatoes, and garlic aioli.
Oven roasted turkey, artichoke, tomatoes, greens, and chipotle mayonnaise.
Grilled roasted chicken, roasted tomatoes, melted fresh mozzarella, and basil pesto spread.
Black forest ham, Swiss cheese, tomatoes, greens, chipotle mayonnaise.
Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, greens, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
Smoked turkey, avocado, Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, greens, tomato, and garlic aioli.
Chopped chicken breast tossed with mayonnaise and celery, crispy bacon, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, greens, and garlic aioli.
Black forest ham, honey glazed turkey, jarlsberg Swiss cheese, sharp Cheddar, Romaine, lettuce, and honey Dijon spread.
Home style tuna salad, melted sharp cheddar, greens, and tomatoes.
Portobello mushrooms, avocado, tomatoes, sprouts, fresh goat cheese, and creamy balsamic vinaigrette
House made egg salad, Swiss cheese, greens, tomatoes, scallions, kosher salt, cracked, and pepper.
Fresh made mozzarella, roasted tomato, spinach, and basil pesto spread.
Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
No mayonnaise. Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
Served with bagel lettuce, sliced tomato, and Bermuda onions coleslaw.
Romaine lettuce with oven roasted turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, tomato, corn, crispy tortillas, onions, and tangy chipotle lime dressing.
Kale with grilled chicken, kalamata olives, shredded feta, Mediterranean cucumbers, Bermuda onion, and creamy garlic caesar dressing.
Mixed baby greens with grilled chicken, blue cheese, cucumber, sprouts, edamame, egg whites, tomato, and creamy balsamic vinaigrette.
Mixed baby greens with breaded chicken, edamame, mandarin oranges, corn, shredded carrots, Bermuda onion, sliced almonds, and Asian sesame ginger dressing.
Baby spinach with grilled chicken, smoked bacon, chopped tomatoes, edamame, crispy tortillas, jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, and tangy chipotle lime dressing.
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, pecorino romano, Kalamata olives, croutons, hard boiled egg, and creamy garlic caesar dressing.
Romaine lettuce with smoked turkey, avocado, Mediterranean cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, Swiss cheese, and low fat peppercorn ranch dressing.
Romaine lettuce with oven roasted turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, tomato, corn, crispy tortillas, onions, and tangy chipotle lime dressing.
Kale with grilled chicken, kalamata olives, shredded feta, Mediterranean cucumbers, Bermuda onion, and creamy garlic caesar dressing.
Mixed baby greens with grilled chicken, blue cheese, cucumber, sprouts, edamame, egg whites, tomato, and creamy balsamic vinaigrette.
Mixed baby greens with breaded chicken, edamame, mandarin oranges, corn, shredded carrots, Bermuda onion, sliced almonds, and Asian sesame ginger dressing.
Baby spinach with grilled chicken, smoked bacon, chopped tomatoes, edamame, crispy tortillas, jalapenos, pepper jack cheese, and tangy chipotle lime dressing.
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, pecorino romano, Kalamata olives, croutons, hard boiled egg, and creamy garlic caesar dressing.
Romaine lettuce with smoked turkey, avocado, Mediterranean cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, Swiss cheese, and low fat peppercorn ranch dressing.
Made with broccoli, mushrooms & bell peppers. Served with home fried or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
2 Eggs, 2 Pancakes, 2 Sausage Patties, 2 Bacon Strips
Served with Home-Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread
Made with Bermuda Onions, Bell Peppers & Diced Tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Made with Nova Scotia Salmon,Eggs & Bermuda Onions serverd with Home Fries or Lettuce & Tomato and Your Choice of Bagel or Bread
Ham peppers and onions. served with a bagel butter and home fries.
Made with sharp Vermont cheddar, Jarlsberg Swiss Cheese & American Cheese. Served with home fries or lettuce and tomatoes Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
One Egg, One Pancake, One Sausage Patty, One Bacon Strip
Made with Feta cheese, Kalamata olives & Beef Stake tomatoes. Served with home fries or lettuce & tomato. Comes with your choice of bagel or bread.
Boiled until the yolk and whites become solid. flat sweet cake.
Flat sweet cake.
Variety of chopped fruit.
Porridge.
Please specify how many of each you want in the special instructions box.
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing.
Cold salad with shredded tuna. chilled creamy mild fish sandwich.
Chopped chicken that has been tossed in a creamy dressing.
Served with a bagel lettuce sliced tomato cucumber bermuda onions and coleslaw.
Chicken Salad Platter
Whitefish Salad Platter
Home-Style Tuna Salad Platter
Baked Salmon Salad Platter
Served with a bagel lettuce sliced tomato cucumber bermuda onions and coleslaw.
Served with your choice of bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, cucmumbers,Bermuda onion on a bed of lettuce
Bacon lettuce and tomato.
Poultry sandwich.
Thinly sliced meat from a pig's leg.
Smoked and cured beef sandwich.
Boneless skinless chicken sandwich.
Breaded chicken tomato sauce and cheese sandwich.
Sandwich with thinly sliced beef that has been cooked over a dry heat.
Cured sausage sandwich.
Salt cured beef sandwich.
Mild cheese sandwich.
Smooth savory cheese sandwich.
Mild cheese sandwich.
Mild medium hard cheese sandwich.
Mild cheese sandwich.
Soft smoked mellow cheese sandwich.
Spicy cheese sandwich.
Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, Romaine lettuce, Plum tomatoes, & Light mayonaise. (Recommended on Country Sour Dough)
Smoked turkey, Avocado, Swiss cheese, Crispy bacon, Romaine lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Drizzled EVOO. (Recommended On Plain Bagel)
Hot pastrami, Melted Swiss cheese, Spicy Mustard & Garlic Aioli . (Recommended on Seeded Rye)
Grilled chicken, Smoked Bacon, Romaine lettuce, Plum tomatoes, & Creamy herbed Mayonaise. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Hot corned beef, Melted Muesnter cheese, Sauerkraut, Spicy golden mustard. (recommended on Seeded Rye)
Home-style Tuna Salad, Melted Vermont Cheddar, Mixed Baby Greens, & Plum Tomato. (Recommended on Hearty Multi-Grain Bread)
Oven roasted chicken breast, Crispy bacon, Swiss cheese, Mixed baby greens, & Light mayonaise. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Hard salami, Blackforest Ham, Provolone cheese, Romaine lettuce , Beefstake tomatoes, Artichoke Pesto & EVOO. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Black forest ham, Honey glazed turkey, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Vermon cheddar cheese, Romaine lettuce & Honey dijon spread. (Recommended on Sesame Bagel)
Portobello mushrooms, Avocado, Sprouts, Plum tomatoes, Fresh Goat cheese & Creamy Balsamic Vinagrette. (Recommended on Plain Bagel)
Home-made Egg Salad, Romaine Lettuce, Plum Tomatoes, Kosher Salt, & Cracked Black Pepper. (Recommended on a Everything Bagel)
Black forest ham, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Plum tomatoes, Romaine lettuce & Garlic Aioli. (Recommended on Country SOur Dough)
Fresh Made Mozzarella, Plum Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers & Basil Pesto Spread. (Recommended on Rustic Square)
Oven roasted turkey, Artichoke, Tomato, Mixed baby greens, & Artichoke pesto. (Recommended on Ciabatta Square)
Hot roast beef, Vermont cheddar, Carmelized onions, Romaine lettuce, Beefstake tomatoes & Russian dressing. (Recommended on a Sesame Bagel)
Made with Hellman's Light Mayo
Made with Hellman's Real Mayo
Baked salmon salad platter
Chocolate
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)Last updated August 4, 2023