0.87 mi
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Diner
Cafe
Subs & Sandwiches
1026 1ST AVE, NEW YORK, NY, 10022
Wed 6:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Sutton Cafe
Order from Sutton Cafe and you're ordering from a diner that is one of the most well-liked in New York. And your order from Sutton Cafe will be a great deal too when you select the most affordable delivery or takeout option shown on this page. The folks at Sutton Cafe know how to run a great diner, so you can feel excited about ordering Sutton Cafe today!
Online Ordering Options
(See pickup options)delivery.combest deal
$0.00
Est. Fee
54 minEst. Time
Menu
- delivery.com
- DoorDash
Eggs & Omelette PlattersGriddle SpecialtiesOdds & EndsFresh BeginningsAppetizersSpa Delights & SaladsHomemade WrapsStuffed Baked PotatoSandwichesTriple Decker Clubs SandwichSpecialty SandwichesSteak Burgers (8 oz)Hot Pressed PaniniHot Open SandwichesMediterranean SpecialsStuffed Pasta FiestaEntreesSide OrdersDessertsBeverages
Eggs & Omelette Platters
One Egg Any Style Platter (Eggs Only)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$8.75
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Ham)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$11.25
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$11.25
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Sausage)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$11.75
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Canadian Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.25
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Turkey Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.25
One Egg Any Style Platter (With Turkey Sausage)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.25
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (Eggs Only)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$9.94
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Ham)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.95
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.95
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Sausage)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$12.95
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Canadian Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$13.45
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Turkey Bacon)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$13.45
Two Eggs Any Style Platter (With Turkey Sausage)
Additional charge to add your choice of ham, bacon, sausage, Canadian bacon, turkey bacon or turkey sausage.
$13.45
Create Your Own Omelette Platter
Your choice of one: mushrooms, broccoli, ham, bacon, spinach, spinach, tomato, Spanish cheese, green peppers, onion or Western. Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$13.45
Feta Omelette Platter
Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$13.45
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs Platter
$14.95
Plain Omelette Platter
$11.45
Veggie Omelette Platter
Tomato, onions, mushroom and broccoli. Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$14.45
Florentine Omelette Platter
Feta cheese, spinach and onion. Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$14.45
Greek Omelette Platter
Feta cheese, tomato and onion. Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$14.45
Nova & Onions Omelette Platter
Additional charge to add extra omelette mix-ins.
$19.95
Steak & Eggs Platter
$22.95
Griddle Specialties
Plain Griddle
Challah french toast, pancakes or beligan waffle.
$12.95
Plain Griddle with 2 Eggs
Challah french toast, pancakes or beligan waffle.
$15.45
Plain Griddle with Blueberries
Challah french toast, pancakes or beligan waffle.
$15.45
Lumberjack
Challah french toast, pancakes or beligan waffle.
$18.45
Silver Dollar Pancakes
$14.45
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$16.45
Walnut Pancakes
$16.45
Belgian Waffle Sundae
With a scoop of ice cream, syrup and whipped cream.
$18.45
Odds & Ends
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$4.95
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Nova
$15.95
Bagel Platter
With cream cheese, nova, lettuce, tomato, onions and olives.
$19.45
Cheese Danish
$3.75
Apple Turnover
$3.75
Pound Cake
Choice of plain, marble or lemon ice pound cake.
$3.75
Bagel
$2.95
Pita
$2.95
English Muffin
$2.95
Large English Muffin
$3.35
Toast
Choice of white, whole wheat, rye or multigrain bread.
$2.75
Roll
$2.75
Homemade Muffin
$4.15
Jumbo Cookie
Choice of black & white, chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin cookie.
$4.15
Hot Oatmeal
$7.25
Avocado Toast
$7.95
Fresh Beginnings
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice (Small (10 oz.))
$5.95
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice (Large (16 oz.))
$6.95
Tomato Juice (Small (10 oz.))
$4.95
Tomato Juice (Large (16 oz.))
$5.95
Apple Juice (Small (10 oz.))
$4.95
Apple Juice (Large (16 oz.))
$5.95
V8 100% Vegetable Juice
$4.25
Pineapple Juice (Individual)
$4.25
Half Grapefruit Juice
$4.95
Fresh Fruit Salad
$7.25
Melon
Your choice of watermelon or honeydew melon.
$6.95
Appetizers
Chicken Fingers
Served with your choice of honey mustard or barbecue sauce.
$12.95
Homemade French Fried Onion Rings
$8.94
Fried Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara Sauce
$10.95
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Your choice of hot or mild. Served with blue cheese or ranch dressing.
$12.95
Shrimp Tenders
Your choice of hot or mild. Served with homemade marinara sauce.
$14.95
Stuffed Grape Leaves
Stuffed with rice and spices.
$9.94
Homemade Chili (Small)
$7.45
Homemade Chili (Large)
$9.44
Spa Delights & Salads
Greek Salad (Small)
Lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, cucumbers, olives, anchovies, feta cheese and stuffed grape leaves. Additional charge to add chicken or grilled shrimp.
$15.45
Greek Salad (Large)
Lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, cucumbers, olives, anchovies, feta cheese and stuffed grape leaves. Additional charge to add chicken or grilled shrimp.
$18.45
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast on top of mixed greens and tomato.
$19.45
Slim-Line Salad
Your choice of 8 ounce steak or turkey burger with a scoop of cottage cheese, lettuce and tomato salad.
$18.45
Tuna Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumber.
$15.45
Chicken Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumber.
$15.45
Egg Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumber.
$15.45
Cantaloupe & Cottage Salad
$12.45
Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special caesar dressing. Additional charge to add chicken or grilled shrimp.
$13.95
Chef's Salad
Julienne of ham, roast beef, turkey, your choice of cheese, hard-boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.
$20.45
Health Salad
Fresh fruit salad, cottage cheese and Jello-O on a bed of lettuce.
$18.45
Turkey Bowl Salad
Fresh sliced turkey over mixed greens and tomato salad.
$19.45
Large Mixed Green Salad
$13.45
Tuna Fish Salad Platter (No Celery)
Tuna fish salad (no celery) with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
Chicken Salad Platter (No Celery)
Chicken salad (no celery) with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
Egg Salad Platter (No Celery)
Egg salad (no celery) with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
Salad Nicoise
Chunks of tuna over mixed with hard boiled egg, olives, green beans, tomato and anchovies.
$19.45
Horiatiki Salad
Tomato, cucumber, onions and feta cheese with grilled chicken.
$19.45
Sutton Cafe Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onions and olives with hamburger or turkey burger.
$19.45
Baked Potato Vegetable Plate
$19.45
Baked Sweet Potato Vegetable Plate
$19.45
Homemade Wraps
Turkey Club Wrap
Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato.
$15.95
Sutton Cafe Wrap
Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
$15.95
Hot Roast Beef Wrap
Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sauteed mushrooms.
$15.95
Roast Beef Wrap
Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
$15.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.
$15.95
Chicken Salad Wrap
Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
$15.95
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sauteed onions.
$15.95
Hot Pastrami Wrap
Grilled pastrami with melted Swiss cheese.
$15.95
Nova Wrap
Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce and tomato.
$18.95
Tuna Fish Salad Wrap
Tasty homemade tuna fish salad with lettuce and tomato.
$15.95
Stuffed Baked Potato
Stuffed Baked Potato with Broccoli and Cheese
$12.45
Stuffed Baked Potato with Bacon
$15.70
Sandwiches
Fried Egg Sandwich (Regular)
$5.25
Fried Egg Sandwich (With Ham)
$8.94
Fried Egg Sandwich (With Bacon)
$8.94
Fried Egg Sandwich (With Sausage)
$8.94
Western Egg Sandwich
Ham, peppers and onions.
$8.94
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich
$9.94
Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Regular)
Your choice of cheese.
$9.94
Grilled Cheese Sandwich (With Ham)
Your choice of cheese.
$12.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich (With Bacon)
Your choice of cheese.
$12.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich (With Turkey)
Your choice of cheese.
$12.95
Cheese Sandwich
Your choice of cheese: American, Swiss, mozzarella, cheddar or Muenster.
$9.94
Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich
No celery.
$11.95
Chicken Salad Sandwich
No celery.
$11.95
Egg Salad Sandwich (Regular)
$10.95
Egg Salad Sandwich (With Bacon)
$13.95
Roast Turkey Sandwich
Carved to order.
$13.95
Roast Beef Sandwich
$13.95
Virginia Ham Sandwich
$12.45
Corned Beef Sandwich
$13.95
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$13.95
Meat Loaf Sandwich
$12.95
Turkey Meat Loaf Sandwich
$12.95
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
$13.95
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Choice of cheese.
$13.95
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
$13.95
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich
$15.45
Fried Filet Sandwich
$12.95
Individual Tuna Sandwich
$12.95
Individual Salmon Sandwich
$12.95
S & S Sardines Sandwich
$12.95
Triple Decker Clubs Sandwich
1. Turkey Triple Decker Club
Fresh sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
2. Roast Beef Triple Decker Club
With Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
3. Grilled Chicken Triple Decker Club
Grilled breast of chicken with your choice of cheese, lettuce and tomato.
$19.45
4. Chicken Salad Triple Decker Club
Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$18.45
5. Tuna Salad Triple Decker Club
Tuna salad with sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.
$18.45
6. Egg Salad Club Triple Decker Club
Egg salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$18.45
Specialty Sandwiches
House Chicken Breast Specialty Sandwich
Grilled breast of chicken, topped with sauteed onions and melted cheese on pita.
$17.45
Chicken Pita Pizza Specialty Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on pita.
$17.45
First Avenue Specialty Sandwich
Thin sliced roast beef topped with sauteed mushrooms and melted cheese, garnished with potato salad.
$19.45
Monte Cristo Specialty Sandwich
Thin sliced turkey with ham and melted Swiss cheese over Challah French toast.
$19.45
Chicken Salad Melt Specialty Sandwich
Served with choice of french fries or potato salad or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Tuna Salad Melt Specialty Sandwich
Served with choice of french fries or potato salad or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Open Reuben Specialty Sandwich
Your choice of pastrami or corned beef with sauerkraut, topped with melted Swiss on grilled rye bread and garnished with potato salad.
$19.45
Pastrami Grill Specialty Sandwich
Grilled hot pastrami on rye with choice of melted cheese.
$19.45
Grilled Eggplant Specialty Sandwich
Grilled eggplant, peppers, red onion and melted mozzarella on a bun with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Chicken Nuggets Basket
Your choice of honey mustard or barbecue sauce. Served with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$18.45
Chicken Fingers Basket
Your choice of honey mustard or barbecue sauce. Served with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Fish & Chips Basket
Served with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Fried Fish Specialty Sandwich Deluxe
On your choice of bread with lettuce and tomatoes. Served with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Open Sliced Steak Specialty Sandwich
Sliced steak on toast, open faced with lettuce, tomato. Served with french fries or for an extra charge: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$24.45
Sutton Meat Loaf Specialty Sandwich
With mashed potatoes, crispy onions and barbecue gravy served open-faced on thick egg bread. Additional charge to substitute mashed potatoes for: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Gyro on Pita
With lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.
$12.45
Gyro Platter
With Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce. Additional charge to substitute french fries for: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Chicken Souvlaki on Pita
With lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.
$12.45
Chicken Souvlaki Platter
With Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce. Additional charge to substitute french fries for: baked potato, baked sweet potato, fried onion rings or sweet potato fries.
$19.45
Steak Burgers (8 oz)
Steak Burger
$9.75
Garden Burger
$9.75
Chili Burger
$10.75
Turkey Burger
$9.94
Pizza Burger
Topped with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.
$11.50
Steak Cheese Burger
Your choice of American, Swiss, Muenster or cheddar cheese.
$11.25
Greek Burger
Sauteed spinach, feta cheese and onion.
$14.75
Cali Burger
Avocado, bacon and cheddar cheese.
$14.75
Mex Burger
Avocado, jalapeno peppers and cheddar.
$14.75
Rodeo Burger
Mushrooms, onions and muenster cheese.
$14.75
Italian Burger
Roasted red peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese.
$14.75
Hot Pressed Panini
Grilled Chicken Panini
Sliced chicken breast, mozzarella cheese, basil and roasted red peppers, sprinkled with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
$19.45
Roast Beef & Mozzarella Panini
Sliced roast beef topped with mozzarella.
$19.45
Turkey Panini
Sliced turkey topped with Swiss cheese and grilled tomato, served with a side of honey Dijon dressing.
$19.45
Chicken Parmigiana Panini
Pan fried chicken topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
$19.45
Italian Panini
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette and fresh mozzarella.
$19.45
Greek Panini
Grilled chicken, Feta cheese, tomato and spinach, served with tzatziki sauce.
$19.45
Hot Open Sandwiches
Hot Open Freshly Sliced Roast Beef Sandwich
$20.45
Hot Open Freshly Carved Turkey (Off The Bone) Sandwich
$20.45
Mediterranean Specials
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$16.45
Pasta with Meat Sauce
Spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$20.45
Pasta with Meatballs
Spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$20.45
Lasagna
$20.45
Vegetarian Lasagna
$20.45
Spinach Pie
$20.45
Eggplant Parmigiana
Served with spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$20.45
Chicken Cutlet
Served with spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$22.45
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Served with spaghetti, linguine, penne or whole wheat pasta.
$24.45
Stuffed Pasta Fiesta
Imported Cheese Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with Ricotta cheese and Pecorino Romano cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
$20.45
Beef Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with sauteed beef and a blend of spices and cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
$20.45
Spinach Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with spinach, Ricotta cheese and Pecorino Romano cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
$20.45
Stuffed Rigatoni
Homemade rigatoni stuffed with Ricotta cheese and Pecorino Romano cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
$20.45
Stuffed Shells
Homemade jumbo pasta shells, stuffed with Ricotta cheese and Pecorino Romano cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
$20.45
Entrees
Turkey Entree
Carved roast turkey breast, served with cranberry sauce with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Grilled Chicken Breast - Athenian Style
Marinated in fresh garlic, lemon and herbs, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Poached Chicken Breast Entree
With a balsamic black bean and pepper salsa, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Roasted Half Chicken Entree
Served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Chicken Breast Florentine
Broiled breast of chicken stuffed with imported Feta cheese, spinach and herbs, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Chicken Kebob
Chunks of chicken breast sauteed with bell peppers, onions and tomatoes served over rice.
$24.45
Southern Fried Chicken
Honey dipped Louisiana style fried chicken, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Turkey Meatloaf
Slowly baked turkey meatloaf, served with homemade mushroom gravy and your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Baked Meatloaf
Served with mushroom gravy and with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Broiled Rib Eye Steak
Topped with garlic flavored sauteed mushrooms, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$28.45
Chopped Steak
Topped with choice of sauteed onion or bacon, served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$24.45
Broiled Norwegian Salmon
Served with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$25.45
Poached Norwegian Salmon
Served with a creamy dill sauce and with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$25.45
Fish Filet Ala Maison
Cooked in white wine garlic, served with with your choice of vegetable and your choice of potato.
$25.45
Shrimp Primavera
Gulf shrimp and diced vegetables, sauteed in garlic and herbs, served over your choice of pasta or rice.
$29.45
Side Orders
Side of French Fries
$6.45
Side of Cheese Fries
$8.94
Side of Sweet Potato Fries
$7.95
Side of Baked Potato
Only Available After 12:00 pm.
$7.45
Side of Baked Sweet Potato
Only Available After 12:00 pm.
$7.25
Side of Home Fried Potato
$6.45
Side of Mashed Potatoes
$6.45
Side of Pasta with Marinara Sauce
$10.95
Side of Pasta with Olive Oil & Garlic
$10.95
Side of Sauteed Vegetable
$9.94
Side of Vegetable
$8.25
Side of Rice
$5.95
Mixed Green Side Salad
$7.95
Side of Ham
$8.94
Side of Bacon
$8.94
Side of Sausage
$8.94
Side of Canadian Bacon
$9.94
Side of Turkey Bacon
$9.94
Side of Turkey Sausage
$9.94
Side of Corned Beef Hash
$9.94
Side of Cole Slaw
$6.45
Side of Potato Salad
$6.45
Side of Cottage Cheese
$6.25
Side of Cranberry Sauce
$5.75
Side of Tzatziki Sauce (10 oz)
$6.95
Side of Salad Dressing (10 oz.)
$6.95
Caesar Side Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special Caesar dressing.
$7.95
Desserts
Jello-O
$4.75
Chocolate Layer Cake
$7.25
Creamy Cheese Cake
$7.25
Fruit Pie
$6.25
Fruit Pie A La Mode
$8.25
Creamy Rice Pudding
$6.95
Ice Cream (One Scoop)
$4.95
Ice Cream (Two Scops)
$7.95
Beverages
Coffee (Small (10 oz.))
$2.25
Coffee (Large (16 oz.))
$2.50
Tea (Small (10 oz.))
$2.25
Tea (Large (16 oz.))
$2.50
Decaffeinated Cofee (Small (10 oz.))
$2.25
Decaffeinated Cofee (Large (16 oz.))
$2.50
Herbal Tea
$2.50
Hot Chocolate
$2.95
Hot Chocolate with Milk
$4.45
Espresso
$4.25
Double Espresso
$5.50
Cappuccino
$6.25
Whole Milk (Small)
$3.75
Whole Milk (Large)
$4.75
Chocolate Milk (Small)
$3.75
Chocolate Milk (Large)
$4.75
Iced Cappuccino
$6.95
Iced Coffee
$3.50
Iced Tea
$3.50
Ice Cream Soda
$7.95
Fresh Lemonade
$6.25
Fountain Soda
$2.75
Egg Cream
Choice of vanilla or chocolate.
$4.75
Milk Shake
$6.95
Thick Milk Shake
$7.95
Last updated August 4, 2023
delivery.combest deal
$0.00
Est. Fee
54 minEst. Time