Back
The Pony Bar (1st Ave) Logo

The Pony Bar (1st Ave)

1.51mi
1444 1st Avenue, New York, NY, 10021
Not Available Now (Available Fri 3:00 PM - Sat 1:30 AM)Call Now
Claim My Restaurant

About The Pony Bar (1st Ave)

Order from The Pony Bar (1st Ave) and you're ordering from a pub that is one of the most well-liked in New York. And your order from The Pony Bar (1st Ave) will be a great deal too when you selec...show more

Menus

Salad
Simple Mixed Greens
$8.00

Served with beer mustard vinaigrette.

Sandwiches
The Pony Bar Burger
$13.00

6oz Angus patty, iceberg lettuce, tomato, pickles, soft bun. Comes with a choice of house cut chips or coleslaw.

Pulled Pork Sandwich
$12.00
Fennel Sausage Sandwich
$12.00

Marinara, provolone cheese.

Spicy Korean Fried Chicken Sandwich
$12.00
Grilled Cheese
Traditional Three Cheese Blend Sandwich
$11.00

Comes with a choice of house cut chips or coleslaw.

Pimento Cheese & Brown Sugar Washed Bacon Sandwich
$12.00

Comes with a choice of house cut chips or coleslaw.

Short Rib & Traditional Three Cheese Blend Sandwich
$13.00

Comes with a choice of house cut chips or coleslaw.

Tacos
Carne Asada Tacos
$4.00

Comes with radishes, lime and guacamole

Pollo Tacos
$4.00

Comes with radishes, lime and guacamole

Carnitas Tacos
$4.00

Comes with radishes, lime and guacamole

Tasty Plates
Skillet Sausages
$12.00

Overnight brown sugar/molasses marinade, mustard.

Molasses Marinade & Mustard
$12.00
Hummus & Crudites
$9.00
Soft Pretzel
$9.00

Mustard & pimento cheese.

General Tso’s Cauliflower
$9.00
Naked Calamari
$12.00

Thai chili sauce.

Pigs in a Blanket
$9.00

Cheddarwurst, pastry crust.

Green Bean Tempura & Mustard
$10.00
House Cut Chips
$6.00

Malt vinegar.

Double Fried Wings
Brined Wings
$13.99

8 wings per order; mild, medium, hot or BBQ, blue cheese & sticks.

Online Ordering Options

(See pickup options)
PostmatesNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range
$0.00
Est. Fee
56 minEst. Time
Place Order
PostmatesNot Delivering: Outside of delivery range
$0.00
Est. Fee
56 minEst. Time
Place Order

Last updated February 12, 2020